Factors Influencing the Improvement of Students’ Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving Skill: An Industrial Training Intervention

Abstract

Critical thinking and problem solving skill is important for university students to increase their chances of securing a work placement. One way to improve this skill is believed through experiences gained from an industrial training. This study aims to investigate the impact of industrial training on the improvement of students’ critical thinking and problem solving skill. Further, it aims to explore the influence of selected factors on this skill improvement. These selected factors are demographic profiles of students, supervisors and organization, students’ motivation, job scope, supervisor leadership styles and organizational culture. The study adapted Belbin Team Role Self-Perception Inventory as the research instrument of the re-search. A total of 1,227 students and 485 students from six public universities in Malaysia, have completed the pre survey and post survey respectively. Using paired t-test analysis, result exhibited that students’ shown improvement in their critical thinking and problem solving upon completion of their industrial training. The results also exhibited that this skill improvement is best predicted when students performed independence job scope, being supervised by male supervisor and the supervisor and when the supervisors exercise transformational leadership styles. Some practical and empirical implications were drawn from the findings of this study.

Model Peningkatan Kinerja Dosen Universitas Boyolali di Jawa Tengah Sebuah pendekatan Fourfold C Character

“…Creativity and Innovation (kreatifitas dan inovasi). Creativity and Innovation merupakan suatu kemampuan untuk menyampaikan dan mengembangkan gagasan-gagasan baru kepada pihak lain, bersikap responsif dan menerima dengan terbuka terhadap perspektif yang baru dan berbeda (Rodzalan et al 2019). Kreativitas telah menjadi semboyan di zaman kontemporer: menjadi kreatif adalah satu-satunya cara untuk melakukan apa pun dan moda bertahan yang paling jitu.…”

“…Critical Thinking and Problem Solving (berpikir kritis dan pemecahan masalah). Critical Thinking and Problem Solving merupakan suatu kemampuan untuk memahami sebuah masalah yang kompleks, yang memunculkan perspektif karena mampu mengoneksikan satu informasi dengan informasi lainnya, dan menemukan solusi yang tepat untuk suatu permasalahan (Rodzalan et al 2019). Pemikiran kritis dan keterampilan pemecahan masalah penting dalam meningkatkan kelayakan kerja lulusan untuk memastikan bahwa mereka mampu dalam menghadapi kemajuan dalam konteks kerja (Holmes 2013).…”

“…Kemampuan Dosen untuk Critical Thinking and Problem Solving diharapkan mampu ditularkan pada mahasiswanya untuk meningkatkan pemikiran kritis dan keterampilan memecahkan masalah (Jackson 2014). Sebuah studi oleh Dvergsten dan Haugen (Rodzalan et al 2019) menggunakan studi pra dan pasca menemukan bahwa pembelajaran berdasarkan pengalaman adalah cara yang efektif untuk meningkatkan keterampilan berpikir kritis siswa.…”

Application of an Artificial Neural Network to Evaluate the Integration Effect of Quality Education and Skill Education

“…The purpose of skill education is to cultivate students to quickly acquire, master, and apply the vocational skills, experiences, and techniques they learnt to their work positions; skill education is highly professional and job-oriented [1][2][3][4].…”

Problem-oriented Teaching Mode based on Data Mining Technology in the Sports Psychology Classroom

“…This mode has also harvested the recognition of teachers in many subjects in practice. Among them, Rodzalan et al [2] considered that the problem-oriented teaching mode enabled learners to apply the knowledge and skills they have learned, combine theory with practice, and develop a feasible program to solve the problem. Wiek et al [3] drew up a PBL teaching reform plan based on PBL and applied it in Arizona State University's School of Sustainability (SOS).…”