Failing Services on Urban Waste Management in Developing Countries: A Review on Symptoms, Diagnoses, and Interventions

Abstract

The potential and scale of cities enable economic growth and the improvement of citizens’ access to jobs, education, healthcare, culture, public utilities and services. Solid waste management (SWM) is one of the key services provided by cities. Its operations are complex, very visible to the general public, and impacted by strong financial, societal, and political constraints. Performances in developing countries, however, are not positive. United Nations research shows urban collection services covering no more than 39% of the population in low-income countries. Why are many cities in developing countries not able to use their increasing wealth and scale for basic SWM services such as city cleaning, collection, and sustainable landfilling? This paper provides a review of literature on this question over the last decade. It shows that research is mostly on symptoms and has not led to a deeper diagnosis of causes. Lack of resources, infrastructure, awareness, and institutional strength are often pinpointed as causes but, in fact, they should be addressed as symptoms. These symptoms should be designated as dependent variables in a complex causal network with systemic feedbacks, hindering or neutralizing attempts to improve performances if not properly dealt with. Research should concentrate more on assessing the relations between urbanization, urban processes, and urban governance that shape the performance of urban solid waste management. System dynamics modeling may provide new approaches for this diagnosis.

Individual and situational determinants of plastic waste sorting: an experience sampling method study protocol

“…2 Department of Lifespan Psychology, Faculty of Psychology, Open Universiteit, Heerlen, The Netherlands. 3…”

“…For instance, using lighter plastic composites instead of metal in aircrafts results in significant fuel cost savings as well as easier assembly of airplane parts [ 2 ]. However, some of the properties of plastics, such as longevity and resistance to degradation, create a major waste management problem [ 1 ], especially in developing countries [ 3 ]. A global analysis [ 4 ] showed that approximately 6300 metric tons of plastic waste have been generated as of 2015, of which only 9% have been recycled.…”

Innovative Solutions for Local Public Administration in the Process of the Waste Collection

“…Waste collection is an important part of the environmental policies and represents one of the challenges for public authorities worldwide because as urbanization is increasing, especially in developing countries and growth of population. Ineffective waste management and weak policies may lead to the degradation of valuable land resources, a rise in the land price and the creation of long-term environmental and human health problems [2].…”

Municipal Solid Waste Characterization and Landfill Gas Generation in Kakia Landfill, Makkah

“…Thus, it is vital to choose a refuse disposal site that will have a minimal hazardous effect on human health and the environment. Solid waste management (SWM) has five main pillars: Reduction, recycling, recovery, reuse, and disposal [9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17]. Different approaches have been developed to manage MSW, but landfilling has remained the most common approach to manage MSW, mainly in developing countries.…”

“…Due to changes in consumption patterns of commercial and households, the amount of solid waste generated per year has increased globally [9]. Improper management of this waste has led to many environmental problems like contamination of surface and groundwater bodies [18], air pollution [6], lack of land [19], and potential financial obligations [13,18,19].…”