Fairness in Transport Policy: A New Approach to Applying Distributive Justice Theories

Abstract

The transport system influences everyone’s wellbeing on a daily basis. These impacts are both positive and negative and are borne directly and indirectly at a range of spatial and temporal scales and across different groups in society. Furthermore, they are often distributed unfairly and the people who are least able to use transport networks frequently bear the greatest costs. People also have various transport needs and these needs change throughout their lives. Due to these complexities, there is no straightforward answer as to how we should provide transport fairly. Policies and actions to decarbonise the transport system are urgently needed, but their equity effects are also important. We give a brief overview of distributive justice and equity in transport literature. We then develop a conceptual framework of distributive justice and a set of four principles to guide the application of the framework to transport policy. We then apply these to recent transport policies in Aotearoa/New Zealand, a country that shares common features with most highly motorised countries. We apply the Capabilities Approach to transport policy in a novel way that conceptualises transport policy as a social conversion factor which influences people’s ability to convert resources and opportunities into the things (‘beings and doings’) that they have reason to value. The consideration of transport policy as a conversion factor, rather than focusing on a specific capability, emphasises the role of transport policy as a promoter of a wide range of capabilities and highlights the inequitable distribution of positive and negative effects on people’s health and wellbeing. It also illuminates issues of power structures and procedural fairness in transport policy that are otherwise not covered by distributive justice approaches. Taking a broader view of distributive justice theory in transport provides a clearer picture of the impacts of transport on wellbeing and provides theory-based guidance on the actions to improve transport justice that can be readily integrated into existing policy institutions.

The Impact of Transport on Population Health and Health Equity for Māori in Aotearoa New Zealand: A Prospective Burden of Disease Study

“…The policy lessons from tobacco control (and public health more generally) are likely to be helpful to understand the most effective approaches to re-shaping the transport system into one that promotes health and reduces inequity [ 47 , 48 , 49 ]. This reshaping will require shifting transport policy away from being an economic and technical issue to being a central part of social policy, bringing with it the duties and responsibilities that social policy requires [ 8 ].…”

“…Therefore, specific solutions to achieve a healthier transport system would be a matter for the society affected to consider. This process should pay particular attention to those most disadvantaged and take into account the capabilities and outcomes those people value [ 8 ].…”

“…We also know that the impacts of transport on health are often inequitably distributed [ 7 , 8 ]. In car-dominated transport systems, those that use the transport system least (often the poor, ethnic minorities, and indigenous populations) frequently bear more than their share of the negative effects on health [ 7 ].…”

The Concept of Fairness in Relation to Women Transport Users

“…These can be extended to issues such as distributional equity, which is often evaluated for fairness by examining the accessibility to transport infrastructures but excludes sufficient evaluation of how safely and easily people can travel to the station (see for instance, [33]. Modal equity approaches can be extended to consider the effects of using modes (e.g., the consequences of accidents at different speeds on pedestrians) and which may disproportionately affect certain groups (e.g., children).…”

Mobility and sustainable transportation in higher education: evidence from Monterrey Metropolitan Area in Mexico

“…Education and transportation are at the heart of two Sustainable Development Goals (SDG): quality education (SDG4) and sustainable communities and cities (SDG11). Also, education and mobility are fundamental human rights (Sen, 2005; Jeekel and Martens, 2017; Randal et al , 2020). Individuals attend school to be well-educated, attend the health care centers to be healthy, work to satisfy needs, attend sports, recreation and other places because they have preferences and reasons to value (Sen, 1985).…”