Introduction: Pseudoaneurysms are vascular lesions occurring after injury to a blood vessel wall. Peripheral artery pseudoaneurysms as a fracture complication are uncommon and typically appear immediately after trauma or surgery. We report a unique case of sciatic nerve palsy associated with external iliac artery pseudoaneurysm arising 20 years after pelvic trauma, presenting within the fracture site as an erosive bone lesion masquerading as a possible malignancy. To the best of our knowledge, no cases of delayed external iliac artery pseudoaneurysm involving sciatic pain have been reported. Case Report: We present a 78-year-old female who sustained an acetabular fracture with an uneventful recovery for 20 years. The patient presented post-injury with symptoms and physical examination findings consistent with sciatic nerve palsy. Computed tomography angiography and duplex imaging revealed a pseudoaneurysm of the external iliac artery. The patient was taken to the operating room for endovascular repair of the external iliac artery using a covered stent. Conclusion: This case of sciatic nerve palsy is a unique contribution to the literature concerning the specific vascular injury observed and the delayed presentation of pseudoaneurysm causing sciatic nerve palsy. Orthopedic surgeons must consider a wide differential when confronted with suspicious pelvic masses. Failure to diagnose these as a vascular etiology could prove catastrophic should the surgeon attempt an open debridement or sampling. Keywords: Pseudoaneurysm, false aneurysm, sciatic nerve palsy, pelvis fracture, bone lesion.