Features and Educational Content Related to Milk Production in Breastfeeding Apps: Content Analysis Informed by Social Cognitive Theory

Abstract

Background Low milk production is one of the main reasons for premature breastfeeding cessation. Smartphone apps have the potential to assist mothers with promoting, interpreting, tracking, or learning about milk production. It is not known whether breastfeeding apps contain high-quality, engaging, and diverse content and features that could be used by mothers to increase their breastfeeding self-efficacy and answer their questions about milk production. Objective The overarching objective of this study was to identify and evaluate features and content within breastfeeding apps that could be used by mothers to increase breastfeeding self-efficacy and answer their questions about milk production. The secondary objectives were to quantify the diversity of representation of breastfeeding experiences within breastfeeding apps and to define the type of organization that is most likely to create free apps and/or apps with high-quality, engaging, and diverse features and content related to milk production. Methods Breastfeeding apps were identified in the Apple App Store. All features that assist mothers with tracking, promoting, or interpreting milk production in the first 0-6 months postpartum were noted. Every screen containing educational information about milk production was identified and saved for review. Images of mothers and caretakers within the selected screenshots were assessed. Three scoresheets informed by Social Cognitive Theory were created to evaluate all identified features, educational content, and images representing the breastfeeding experience. Results Forty-one breastfeeding apps were reviewed. Only seven apps contained both features and educational content related to milk production. Thirteen apps that contained educational content related to milk production received a mean combined content and cultural diversity score of 15.3 of 78. Of the 48 photos reviewed in screenshots that contained educational content on milk production, 87.5% (n=42) were of white women and their infants. For-profit companies and large organizations were most likely to create free apps and apps that received high scores on the combined content and diversity or features scoresheet, respectively. Conclusions Features and educational content related to milk production and breastfeeding imagery within breastfeeding apps were evaluated using three novel scoresheets informed by Social Cognitive Theory. Few apps contained both features that promote breastfeeding self-efficacy and high-quality, engaging, educational content with images of diverse caretakers. Thus, it is likely that parents, especially those from minority or low-income groups, have limited options when selecting a breastfeeding app. App developers could use the scoresheets and findings in this review to develop breastfeeding apps that assist mothers with interpreting, tracking, or learning about milk production through high-quality an...

Evaluation of Breastfeeding App Features: Content Analysis Study

“…A total of 40 iPhone and 42 Android apps were included in the final sample (N=82) of which 80 were free to users; only 2 paid iPhone apps remained in the final sample (Figure 1). The final sample is comparable to those of previous infant-feeding app studies, which included 41 to 77 apps [18,20,21].…”

“…The schema contained 87 distinct app characteristics and features. We defined features according to Sidhu et al [21] as any "opportunity for user interaction with the app (e.g., a button)." Descriptive characteristics were derived from the app's download page and included the name of the app, website link, download date, version number, date of last update, developer or seller name and affiliation (ie, commercial, government, nongovernment organization, university, unknown, or other), whether and which experts or end users were involved in the app development process, user rating (ie, number of stars out of 5), number of user reviews, app category (ie, medical, lifestyle, health and fitness, parenting, or other), language options, cost of basic and premium app versions, and age rating (not unlike a movie rating, each platform recommends the minimum maturity level of app content for end users by age, ie, >0, >4, >12, or >17).…”

Effects of educational technologies on maternal self-efficacy in preventing childhood diarrhea: a clinical trial

“…The importance of educational tools based on self-efficacy is recognized in the literature and research has shown that the use of these tools can facilitate learning and improve individuals' self-confidence (17,(20)(21) .…”

Audiovisual and printed technology to prevent childhood diarrhea: A clinical trial

“…Self‐efficacy can interfere with actions and the adhesion of healthy behaviors, impacting the individuals' motivation and directly reflecting on their efforts to achieve a certain objective (O'Halloran et al., 2016). Thus, it is necessary to encourage professionals to develop and apply technologies that promote self‐efficacy, given its impact on health promotion, health education, and social support (Sidhu et al., 2019; You et al., 2020).…”

“…Comparison between countryside and metropolis according to the intervention in the first moment (M0) and in the second moment (M2). Statistical test: Mann-Whitney U test professionals to develop and apply technologies that promote selfefficacy, given its impact on health promotion, health education, and social support (Sidhu et al, 2019;You et al, 2020).…”