“…In one school of thought, the final closure occurred prior to the Permian, mainly including before the Late Devonian and between the Late Devonian [54][55][56] and Early Carboniferous [57][58][59]. In an alternative view, the closing of the PAO occurred during the Permian-Triassic, which can be reclassified as during the late Early Permian [60,61], during the Middle-Late Permian [62][63][64][65], during the Late Permian [4,34,48,66], during the Late Permian-Early Triassic [3,10,11,21,33,35,40,41,50,[67][68][69][70], during the Late Permian-Middle Triassic [5,22,25,26,28,32,42,71,72], and during the Middle-Late Triassic [20,24,37,49,73]. Therefore, substantial controversy remains regarding the closure time of the PAO along the CYS.…”