Increasing nest survival by excluding predators is a goal of many bird conservation programs. However, new exclosure projects should be carefully evaluated to assess the potential risks of disturbance. We tested the effectiveness of predator exclosure fences (hereafter, fences) for nests of critically endangered Florida Grasshopper Sparrows (Ammodramus savannarum floridanus) at a dry prairie site (Three Lakes; 2015-2018) and a pasture site (the Ranch;-2016 in Osceola County, Florida, USA. We installed fences at nests an average of 8 days after the start of incubation, and nest abandonment after fence installation was rare (2 of 149 installations). Predation was the leading cause of failure for unfenced nests at both sites (48-73%). At Three Lakes, nest cameras revealed that mammals and snakes were responsible for 61.5% and 38.5% of predation events, respectively, at unfenced nests. Fences reduced the daily probability of predation (0.016 for fenced nests vs. 0.074 for unfenced nests). The probability that a fenced nest would survive from discovery to fledging was more than double that of unfenced nests (60.4% vs. 27.7%). However, we found no difference in daily nest survival at the Ranch between the year before nests were fenced (2015; 0.874) and the year when all but one nest were fenced (2016; 0.867) because red imported fire ants (Solenopsis invicta) were responsible for 86% of predation events at fenced nests at the Ranch. The use of cameras at fenced nests revealed that site-specific differences in nest predators explained variation in fence efficiency between sites. Our fence design may be useful for other species of grassland birds, but site-specific predator communities and species-specific response of target bird species to fences should be assessed before installing fences at other sites.
RESUMEN.Cercas de exclusi on alrededor de nidos de Ammodramus savannarum floridianus en riesgo disminuyen las tasas de depredaci on por mam ıferos Incrementar la supervivencia de los nidos mediante la exclusi on de depredadores es uno de los objetivos de muchos programas de conservaci on de aves. Sin embargo, nuevos proyectos de exclusi on deben ser evaluados cuidadosamente para determinar el riesgo potencial del disturbio. Evaluamos la efectividad de cercas excluyentes de depredadores (cercas de aqu ı en adelante) para nidos del cr ıticamente amenazado Ammodramus savannarum floridianus en un sitio de pradera seca (Three Lakes; 2019-2018) y un sitio de potrero (the Ranch; 2015-2016) en el condado de Osceola, Florida, USA. Instalamos cercas en los nidos en promedio ocho d ıas despu es del inicio de la incubaci on y el abandono del nido despu es de la instalaci on del acerca fue raro (2 de 149 instalaciones). Depredaci on fue la causa principal de fracaso de los nidos sin cercas en los dos sitios (60.4% vs. 27.7%). Sin embargo, no encontramos diferencias en la supervivencia diaria de los nidos en "the Ranch" entre los años anteriores a la instalaci on de las cercas (2016; 0.874) y el año en el que todos los nidos excepto...