Background
The Gesneriaceae genus
Chiritopsis
, confined almost exclusively to cave or cave-like microhabitats of limestone karsts of southern China, was described to distinguish it from
Chirita
by much smaller flowers and generally miniature plant sizes in the former genus. However, molecular phylogenetic analyses showed that
Chiritopsis
is polyphyletic and its species delimitation has been problematic. To understand how many times Chiritopsis-like species have evolved from within the recircumscribed
Primulina
and to further clarify their species identification, we sampled all but two recently described species of Chiritopsis-like
Primulina
and reconstructed their phylogenetic relationship based on DNA sequences of nuclear ITS and chloroplast
trnL
-
F
and
trnH
-
psbA
.
Results
With 182 accessions of 165 taxa of
Primulina
sampled, our analyses placed the 40 accessions of 25 taxa of Chiritopsis-like
Primulina
in 17 unrelated positions, indicating at least 17 independent origins of the traits associated with caves or cave-like microhabitats. Of the 17 clades containing Chiritopsis-like
Primulina
, Clade 1 is composed of
P. bipinnatifida
,
P. cangwuensis
,
P. jianghuaensis
,
P. lingchuanensis
, and
P. zhoui
, as well as additional samples that show variable and overlapping morphology in leaf shapes. Clade 10 includes
P. cordifolia
,
P. huangii
, and
P. repanda
, while
Primulina repanda
var.
guilinensis
is not placed within Clade 10.
Primulina glandulosa
var.
yangshuoensis
is not placed in the same clade of
P. glandulosa
.
Conclusions
Based on our data,
P. cangwuensis
,
P. jianghuaensis
, and
P. lingchuanensis
are proposed to synonymize under
P. bipinnatifida
, with
P. zhoui
treated as a variety of
P. bipinnatifida
.
Primulina repanda
var.
guilinensis
is transferred as
P. subulata
var.
guilinensis
comb. nov. and
Primulina pseudoglandulosa
nom. nov. is proposed for
P. glandulosa
var.
yangshuoensis
. One new species is named
...