‘Fix the issues at the coalface and mental wellbeing will be improved’: a framework analysis of frontline NHS staff experiences and use of health and wellbeing resources in a Scottish health board area during the COVID-19 pandemic

Abstract

Background Frontline healthcare staff working in pandemics have been reported to experience mental health issues during the early and post-peak stages. To alleviate these problems, healthcare organisations have been providing support for their staff, including organisational, cognitive behavioural and physical and mental relaxation interventions. This paper reports the findings of a study commissioned by a Scottish NHS health board area during the initial outbreak of COVID-19. The study aimed to understand the experience of NHS staff relating to the provision of wellbeing interventions between March and August 2020. Methods Data were gathered from free-text comments of eight surveys completed by a wide range of staff across sites within one NHS health board in Scotland. We conducted a framework analysis of the data. Results Our findings show that despite the provision of relaxational and cognitive behavioural interventions to support staff wellbeing during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, there were barriers to access, including heavy workload, understaffing, inconvenient locations and the stigma of being judged. Organisational factors were the most frequently reported support need amongst frontline staff across sites. Conclusions While relaxational and cognitive behavioural interventions were well received by staff, barriers to accessing them still existed. Staff support in the context of organisational factors, such as engagement with managers was deemed as the most important for staff wellbeing. Managers play a key role in everyday organisational processes and therefore are in the right position to meet increasing frontline staff demands due to the pandemic and removing barriers to accessing wellbeing support. Healthcare managers should be aware of organisational factors that might increase job demands and protect organisational resources that can promote wellbeing for frontline staff.

Cancer staff in an NHS cancer center: infections, vaccination, stress and well-being support during the COVID-19 pandemic

“…The present study found that, although mental well-being resources were available, their level of uptake was hampered by lack of awareness, issues with access and skepticism of their utility. In line with the present study, lack of time, among other access issues, has been highlighted as a major barrier to the use of health and well-being services in other NHS institutions [ 41 , 42 ]. The present study has highlighted this as an area for further improvement within an NHS cancer center.…”

A Review of Clinical Laboratory Education, Training and Progression: Historical Challenges, the Impact of COVID-19 and Future Considerations

“…NHS support for staff mental health and wellbeing was expanded during the pandemic ( 105 ), however a study in Scotland ( 3 ) found that barriers prevented their use for many staff. Although they focussed on front line staff, the key barriers highlighted are likely the same for laboratory workers, e.g., heavy workload, low staffing, and a fear of being judged ( 3 , 110 ). They suggest it’s not enough just to have support resources in place, but organisational plans to allow staff to access resources are required.…”

“…The global impact of COVID-19 and past pandemics on mental health and wellbeing has been well documented (1,2), particularly in patient facing healthcare professionals such as doctors and nurses (3)(4)(5)(6)(7). There is also increasing research regarding the impact on students (8)(9)(10)(11).…”

Self care and wellbeing in the face of COVID-19: Multidisciplinary perspectives and interprofessional experiences

“…More accurately, perhaps, wellbeing priorities have drifted back to concerns surrounding long-term workplace aggravations. 7 Individual interventions have been curtailed as funding, and the will to persevere with time-consuming self-care processes, have dried up. Exhaustion, redeployment, chronic lack of staffing, basics such as lack of parking and the loss of initially overwhelming executive and public support now compound wellbeing fatigue; entrenched issues ‘at the coalface’ stubbornly persist.…”