Floppy swimming: Viscous locomotion of actuated elastica

Abstract

Actuating periodically an elastic filament in a viscous liquid generally breaks the constraints of Purcell's scallop theorem, resulting in the generation of a net propulsive force. This observation suggests a method to design simple swimming devices -which we call "elastic swimmers" -where the actuation mechanism is embedded in a solid body and the resulting swimmer is free to move. In this paper, we study theoretically the kinematics of elastic swimming. After discussing the basic physical picture of the phenomenon and the expected scaling relationships, we derive analytically the elastic swimming velocities in the limit of small actuation amplitude. The emphasis is on the coupling between the two unknowns of the problems -namely the shape of the elastic filament and the swimming kinematics -which have to be solved simultaneously. We then compute the performance of the resulting swimming device, and its dependance on geometry. The optimal actuation frequency and body shapes are derived and a discussion of filament shapes and internal torques is presented. Swimming using multiple elastic filaments is discussed, and simple strategies are presented which result in straight swimming trajectories. Finally, we compare the performance of elastic swimming with that of swimming microorganisms. I. INTRODUCTIONThe fluid mechanics of microorganism locomotion, pioneered more than fifty years ago by G.I. Taylor, has become one of the most successful branches of biomechanics, with success in both the basic physical understanding of flow behavior and the quantitative prediction of kinematics and energetics of locomotion [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8].Recent technical advances have led to ever more precise fabrication at small scales (microns or less), prompting both theorists [9-13] and experimentalists [14] to design and analyze a series of simple low-Reynolds number swimmers. The experiment of Dreyfus et al. [14], in particular, reported locomotion in a sperm-like micro-swimmer, composed of a cargo (red blood cell) and a slender flexible filament made of a series of paramagnetic beads. In that case, actuation by oscillating transverse magnetic fields led to the generation of bending waves propagating along the filament and resulted in the motion of the micro-swimmer. In this system, the right-left symmetry was broken by the presence of a cargo and led to a preferential tip-to-base propagation of the bending waves, resulting in locomotion in the direction base-to-tip.An alternative way to break the symmetry in a similar system would be to build-in the asymmetry in the actuation. In particular, if an elastic filament is periodically actuated at one of its extremities in a viscous liquid, the resulting motion will lead to the propagation of bending waves and, in general, propulsive forces. This idea was originally proposed by Edward Purcell [8]. Physically, actuating an elastic filament allows one to break the constraints of the "scallop theorem" -which states that a body performing a reciprocal motion at low Reynolds number cannot p...

Propulsive force measurements and flow behavior of undulatory swimmers at low Reynolds number

“…1 Strategies for swimming at low Re include ͑i͒ rotation of a helical filament 2,3 and ͑ii͒ actuation of a flexible tail to generate propulsive forces. [4][5][6][7][8] The study of this latter mechanism has been motivated in part by early experimental observations of the propulsion of spermatozoa 9 and has been investigated using resistive force theory by Gray and Hancock. 10,11 In recent years, analytical studies on the motility of micro-organisms at low Re have been complimented by a growing number of experimental investigations.…”

Colloidal Microworms Propelling via a Cooperative Hydrodynamic Conveyor Belt

“…From a fundamental perspective, the transport of microscopic objects in a liquid medium poses the appealing challenge to find an adequate swimming strategy due to the negligible role of inertial force compared to viscous one. At low Reynolds number the Navier-Stokes equations become time reversible [1], and any strategy based on reciprocal motion, i.e., a motion composed by symmetric backward and forward displacements, will fail to produce net propulsion [2].Facing this challenge, the last few years have witnessed the theoretical propositions of several suitable geometries and procedures to propel micromachines in viscous fluids [3][4][5][6][7][8][9]. Parallel advances in miniaturization have led to the generation of new classes of chemically powered [10,11] or externally actuated [12][13][14][15] prototypes with exciting applications in emerging fields such as microsurgery [16,17] or lab-on-a-chip technology [18,19].…”

Theory of Swimming Filaments in Viscoelastic Media

“…Equation (13) must be supplemented by boundary conditions. For simplicity we forbid transverse motion of the head h(0) = 0, and suppose the connection between the head and the flagellum cannot support a moment: h ′′ (0) + 1 0 f m (z)dz = 0 (see [19] for a more realistic treatment of the moment boundary condition). The boundary condition at the other end is zero force, −h ′′′ (1) + f m (1) = 0, and zero moment, h ′′ (1) = 0.…”