Proton-coupled
electron transfer (PCET) plays a key role in many
biological processes, and a thorough comprehension of its subtle mechanistic
complexity requires the synthesis and characterization of suitable
artificial systems capable of mimicking this fundamental, elementary
step. Herein, we report on a detailed photophysical investigation
of conjugate 1, based on a tin(IV) tetraphenylporphyrin
(SnTPP) chromophore bound to two l-tyrosinato amino acids,
in CH2Cl2 in combination with organic bases
of different strength and the preparation of a novel conjugate 3, based on a tin(IV) octaethylporphyrin (SnOEP) in place
of the tetraphenyl analogue, and its photophysical characterization
in CH2Cl2 in the presence of pyrrolidine. In
the case of compound 1 with all bases examined, quenching
of both the singlet and triplet excited states is observed and attributed
to the occurrence of concerted proton–electron transfer (CPET).
Rates and quenching yields decrease with the strength of the base
used, consistent with the decrease of the driving force for the CPET
process. Conjugate 3 with pyrrolidine is quenched only
at the triplet level by CPET, albeit with slower rates than its parent
compound 1, ascribable to the smaller driving force as
a result of SnOEP being more difficult to reduce than SnTPP. For both
systems, the quenching mechanism is confirmed by suitable blank experiments,
specific kinetic treatments, and the observation of kinetic isotope
effects (KIEs). Differently from what has been previously proposed,
a detailed reinvestigation of the triplet quenching of 1 with pyrrolidine shows that no long-lived radical pair state is
formed, as diradical recombination is always faster than formation.
This is true for both 1 and 3 and for all
bases examined. The kinetics of the CPET pathways can be well described
according to Marcus theory and point toward the involvement of substantial
reorganization energy as typically observed for PCET processes of
concerted nature.