Forward Guidance, Pros, Cons and Credibility

Abstract

The goal of the article is to verify the credibility of time contingent Forward Guidance (FG) as well as its possible time-inconsistency based on the rarely addressed example of the National Bank of Poland (NBP). The NBP's FG constitutes a unique case study as this measure in its 'Odyssean' form was not introduced to overcome the limits of further policy rates cuts. It allowed us to verify the FG's credibility and time-inconsistency by applying OLS and GMM estimated contemporaneous and forward looking Taylor type rules with interest smoothing. Our empirical evidence reveals that the annual period of FG in Poland was perceived as a credible promise by consumers. We found that time-consistency could have been an additional factor enhancing the considerable credibility of FG. The satisfying results of the NBP's FG appear to be especially interesting, in particular, when contrasted with the often unfavourable experience with time-contingent FG of prominent central banks. We suppose that to achieve this, the central bank should act with caution and the NBP indeed did so by specifying carefully the short horizon of the commitment to be able to abandon FG when the circumstances change. We also discuss FG by opposing its advantages and the drawbacks indicated in the subject literature.

Macroeconomic effects of unconventional balance sheet policies in the United States and The Euro area

“…This leads to the basic conclusion that quantitative easing is not capable of stimulating long-run growth, but it may be used to buy time for the necessary adjustments when a boost of the real economy and a reduction of uncertainty are the main needs. The article has not accounted for the impact of forward guidance (Maciej Ryczkowski, 2017), although most of the non-standard policy measures have led to expansion of the balance sheet. The article ignored possible nonlinearities in the dynamics of economic variables, which may be especially relevant during financial instability.…”

Money and inflation in inflation-targeting regimes – new evidence from time–frequency analysis

“…The new relevance assigned to money and credit in macroprudential policy and trials to adjust cashless and dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) models with financial frictions might be opposed to the conception of pre-crisis IT. Pre-crisis IT typically relies on the downgraded role of money and the primary importance assigned to the Taylor-type rules and interest rates (Ryczkowski, 2017). The aforementioned discrepancy constitutes a natural background to analyze the association between money growth and inflation in inflation-targeting regimes.…”