It was Thetis, his mother, who planned this (bridal and rest), but even the gods' plans are shaped by another -Eros? Eris? H.D., Helen in Egypt, Part 2: Leuké (L'isle blanche), I.5 Surely the most intriguing and controversial Homeric character is Achilles. Irene de Jong 2018: 43 In Philostratus' dialogue On Heroes (Her.), a Phoenician merchant and a local vinedresser meet at the sanctuary of Protesilaus in Elaeus (Thracian Chersonese). The vinedresser claims to have regular conversations with Protesilaus, the first Greek warrior to die at Troy (Il.2.698-709). The Phoenician gradually comes to believe the vinedresser's claim that he has access to authentic information on the Trojan war. The largest part of the text is devoted to the 'stories of heroes' which the vinedresser 'lavishes' on his guest (τῶν ἡρωικῶν ἡμᾶς λόγων ἐμπέπληκας, 58.2). 1 The eyewitness Protesilaus is the main source, acting both as a reported narrator and as a character in the heroic tales. These are told in a mixture of reported speech and plain narrative. Partly as a result of this change in speech modes, the vinedresser switches between the roles of reporter, interpreter, and seemingly omniscient narrator. The Phoenician merchant is the internal narratee; in the narrative part of the dialogue he is reduced to a prompter.Her. has been interpreted in various ways. Some see it as a truly protreptic dialogue, a promotion of the hero cult in the imperial period; others point to its playful features and 1 Throughout the chapter, the text of Her. is De Lannoy 1977; translations are based on Rusten-König 2014.