“…Budgetary estimates from diffuse benthic REE fluxes, such as SGD or from sedimentary pore water Greaves et al, 1999;Haley and Klinkhammer, 2003;Tachikawa et al, 2003;Johannesson and Burdige, 2007;Schacht et al, 2010;Johannesson et al, 2011Johannesson et al, , 2017Abbott et al, 2015a;Fröllje et al, 2016), suggest that they may dominate the flux of REEs to the oceans. Importantly, such diffuse, or at least hard to quantify, sources are consistent with deep-water isopycnal mixing of ε Nd signals off margins that cannot be explained through surface water sources (Grasse et al, 2012;Grenier et al, 2013). However, while a diffuse benthic source of Nd appears to better describe the dominant flux of REEs to the ocean, outstanding questions remain.…”