This paper presents the results from the studies of the combustion performance of surrogate gasoline fuels in a Ricardo Hydra single-cylinder engine under homogeneous charge compression ignition (HCCI) conditions. The studies at fixed engine speed, intake air temperature, and intake manifold pressure (900 rpm, 200 °C, and 1.8 bar, respectively) demonstrated that fuel chemistry, i.e., the chemical nature of the components and their concentration in the mixture, was strongly correlated to selected parameters of HCCI performance, such as thermal efficiency (η f ), combustion phasing (CA50), and maximum pressure rise rate (MPRR). Using a multivariate optimization method based on desirability functions, it was determined that optimal HCCI combustion performance would be obtained with mixtures rich in isooctane, methylcyclohexane, and toluene (about 30 vol % each), with minimal content of n-heptane and 1-hexene (<10%).