We investigate the electronic and transport properties of topological and non-topological InAs0.85Bi0.15 quantum dots (QDs) described by a ∼ 30 meV gapped Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang (BHZ) model with cylindrical confinement, i.e., "BHZ dots". Via modified Bessel functions, we analytically show that non-topological dots quite unexpectedly have discrete helical edge states, i.e., Kramers pairs with spin-angular-momentum locking similar to topological dots. These unusual non-topological edge states are geometrically protected due to confinement in a wide range of parameters thus remarkably contrasting the bulk-edge correspondence in TIs. Moreover, for a conduction window with four edge states, we find that the two-terminal conductance G vs. the QD radius R and the gate Vg controlling its levels shows a double peak at 2e 2 /h for both topological and trivial BHZ QDs. Our results blur the boundaries between topological and non-topological phenomena for conductance measurements in small systems such as QDs. This is in stark contrast to conductance measurements in 2D quantum spin Hall and trivial insulators. All of these results were also found in HgTe QDs. Bi-based BHZ dots should also prove important as hosts to room-temperature edge spin qubits.