Gender‐Based Pay Discrimination in Otolaryngology

Abstract

Male and female otolaryngologists all attend the same accredited medical schools, complete the same accredited residency programs, and take the same board certification exams; however, female otolaryngologist are paid 77 cents on the dollar compared to their male colleagues. Even after accounting for age, experience, faculty rank, research productivity, and clinical revenue, significant gender pay gaps exist across all professor levels. The goal of this review is to improve our understanding of how and why the gender pay gap and discrimination exists, the harm caused by tolerance of policies that perpetuate gender pay inequity, and what is and can be done to correct gender‐based pay gaps and discrimination. The review presents the current status of gender pay inequity in the United States and reports on how otolaryngology compares to other professions both within and outside of healthcare. The gender pay gap is shown to have a negative impact on economic growth, institutional reputation and financial success, retention and recruitment of faculty, and patient care. Many historically incorrect reasons used to explain the causes of the gender pay gap, including that women work less, have less research productivity, or produce lower‐quality care, have been be disproved by evaluation of current research. Potential causes of gender pay inequities, such as gender bias, organization culture, fear of retaliation, promotions inequalities, lack of transparency, and senior leadership not being held accountable for equity and diversity concerns, will be explored. Finally, examples of best practices to achieve pay equity will be presented. Laryngoscope, 131:989–995, 2021

Gender gap among rhinology and skull base surgeons

“…The dearth of female mentors in leadership positions has been examined as a potential factor for the lag of women entering surgical subspecialties. 7,8 To combat this, the Women in Rhinology (WIR) section of the ARS was established in 2018 and has served as a reservoir of female mentors for current and future female rhinologists. 9 Our review indicates that the percentage of women matriculating into fellowship has remained stable over the past two decades.…”

Gender Disparities in Otolaryngology: A Case Report Reflecting Global Perspectives

“…The literature on gender disparities in otolaryngology focuses mostly on outcomes‐based measures such as research output/funding, 14 leadership positions, 4,5 pay, 11 and recognition awards 12 . Although instrumental, these studies do little to showcase the day‐to‐day biases, microinjuries, and at times blatant discrimination our colleagues face in the workplace.…”

“…Major themes previously identified in the literature on gender inequalities served as a basis for the interview questions. [3][4][5]9,[11][12][13] Table I illustrates the questions utilized in this study. Interviews were conducted via video teleconferencing.…”

Trends in Number of Women Speakers at the American Head and Neck Society Meetings, 2007-2019

“…Conference programs for the AHNS between 2007 and 2019 were downloaded from the official society website. 17 Thirteen final meeting programs from these years were obtained, and each was analyzed for the number of men and women invited to speak in certain categories. Categories included scientific session presenters, scientific session moderators, expert panelists, miscellaneous moderators (including debate, video session, symposium, poster, and best of moderators), and named lecturers/keynote speakers.…”