Gender Role and Relationship Norms among Young Adults in South Africa: Measuring the Context of Masculinity and HIV Risk

Abstract

In the global literature on HIV/AIDS, much attention has been paid to the role of gender inequalities in facilitating the transmission of HIV. For women, gender inequality may be manifested in sexual coercion, reduced negotiating power and partnering with older men, all practices that heighten risk for HIV. Less attention, however, has been paid to how men's relationship behaviors may place them at risk for HIV. Using six culturally specific psychometric scales developed in South Africa, this study examined men's and women's gender role and relationship norms, attitudes and beliefs in the context of ongoing partnerships. These measures were then examined in relation to four sexual risk behaviors: frequency of condom use (with primary or secondary partners) and number of partners (last 3 months and lifetime). Participants were 101 male and 199 female young adults, aged 18-24, recruited from a secondary school in northern KwaZulu/ Natal province. Associations between gender and relationship scale scores and sexual risk outcomes yielded both expected and contradictory findings. For men, more frequent condom use was associated with higher levels of partner attachment (hyper-romanticism) but also with stronger approval of relationship violence and dominant behavior. In contrast, for women, more frequent condom use was correlated with a lower endorsement of relationship violence. Men with lower relationship power scores had fewer sexual partners in the preceding 3 months, while women with more egalitarian sexual scripts reported more sexual partners, as did those with higher hyper-romanticism scores. In logistic regression analysis, more egalitarian relationship norms among men were predictive of less consistent condom use, as were higher relationship power scores for women. These findings are discussed in relation to previous research on gender, heterosexual interactions and masculinity in this area, as well as the implications for HIV prevention programs.

Relationship dynamics and sexual risk behaviour of male partners of female sex workers in Kampala, Uganda

“…However, the men in this study sustained relationships with the sex workers due in part to the health related (access to the clinic the women in our study attended) and financial benefits that accrued, as well as affection for their partner. This was a departure from the conventional male provider role, and starkly contradicted the normative expression of masculinity through that role (Harrison et al, 2006). Economic disempowerment of men and women's greater role in providing for the family undermines masculinity (Silberschmidt, 2001).…”

Factors associated with unprotected sexual practice among men and women with mental illnesses in Brazil

“…Gender-based inequalities, including cultural values (e.g., men should have many partners, women should be monogamous), socioeconomic context (e.g. unequal access to education, employment, increased violence, and restricted reproductive rights among women) which potentially place women at a disadvantage for negotiating safer sex or refusing unwanted sex, can partially explain differential rates of unprotected sex reported among men and women 5,8 .…”

Reconsidering the orphan problem: the emergence of male caregivers in Lesotho

“…In some ways, gender relations have moved toward greater gender equality. In other ways, the dispossession of African males because of these historical shifts, coupled with the maintenance of rural households, has entrenched and reinforced ideas about African patriarchy and authority (Harrison, O'sullivan, Hoffman, Dolezal, & Morrell, 2006;Sideris, 2004). Yet, as Bozzoli (1983) has noted, the complexity of gender relations leads to what she has termed a "patchwork" of patriarchies.…”