“…By contrast, for thin forcing, the evolution of the waves is set by the distance normal to the forcing. This can be seen in the inviscid calculations of Oser (1957), Reynolds (1962), Martin & Llewellyn Smith (2011, 2012 b ) and Davis (2012) for a horizontal disc, Hurley (1969) for an inclined plate and Llewellyn Smith & Young (2003) for a vertical plate, or in the viscous calculations of Kistovich & Chashechkin (1999 a , b ) for a two-dimensional inclined plate, Vasil'ev & Chashechkin (2003, 2006 a , b , 2012) for a three-dimensional inclined plate, Tilgner (2000), Bardakov, Vasil'ev & Chashechkin (2007), Davis & Llewellyn Smith (2010), Le Dizès (2015) and Le Dizès & Le Bars (2017) for a horizontal disc, Maurer etal. (2017) and Boury, Peacock & Odier (2019) for a horizontal wave generator and Beckebanze, Raja & Maas (2019) for a vertical wave generator.…”