We assessed the mechanisms underlying the ability of cocklebur to spread from its natural riverside habitats and establish weedy populations in urban waste areas. We collected fruits from plants growing in natural and urban ruderal habitats and planted 2 maternal families from each of 9 habitat populations in 3 experimental gardens. The gardens were all in full sunlight but differed in the availability of water and nutrient resources. Plant performance in the gardens was measured by numbers and size of fruits produced. Traits known to be associated with cocklebur reproductive success were also measured: times to emergence and anthesis, photosynthetic capacity, mean stomatal conductance, relative growth rate, and biomass allocation to leaves and stems.
Although there were significant differences among populations in the tradeoff between rate of growth in height and timing of anthesis, these population differences were not associated with habitat. Apart from a tendency to produce larger fruits in ruderal populations, there were no detectable differences in the characteristics of plants from natural vs. ruderal habitats. Plants from both habitats did have substantial and significant plastic responses to growth environment. In the three experimental gardens, fruit numbers increased with resource availability but fruit size did not differ significantly. As resource availability increased, plants from both habitats sustained growth longer and became more branchy. Canonical discriminant analysis of all the somatic and reproductive traits together supported the idea that natural and ruderal populations do differ in their overall plastic response to resource availability. The subtly different plastic responses of plants from the two habitats do not arise by substantial adjustments in a few dominant traits, but instead by relatively minor adjustments in a host of functionally interrelated phenological, morphological, and physiological traits. It is these small but coordinated differences in the plastic responses of many traits that appear to differentiate cocklebur from natural vs. weedy urban habitats.