Genomic insights into body size evolution in Carnivora support Peto’s paradox

Abstract

Background The range of body sizes in Carnivora is unparalleled in any other mammalian order—the heaviest species is 130,000 times heavier than the lightest and the longest species is 50 times longer than the shortest. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying these huge differences in body size have not been explored. Results Herein, we performed a comparative genomics analysis of 20 carnivores to explore the evolutionary basis of the order’s great variations in body size. Phylogenetic generalized least squares (PGLS) revealed that 337 genes were significantly related to both head body length and body mass; these genes were defined as body size associated genes (BSAGs). Fourteen positively-related BSAGs were found to be associated with obesity, and three of these were under rapid evolution in the extremely large carnivores, suggesting that these obesity-related BSAGs might have driven the body size expansion in carnivores. Interestingly, 100 BSAGs were statistically significantly enriched in cancer control in carnivores, and 15 of which were found to be under rapid evolution in extremely large carnivores. These results suggested that large carnivores might have evolved an effective mechanism to resist cancer, which could be regarded as molecular evidence to support Peto’s paradox. For small carnivores, we identified 15 rapidly evolving genes and found six genes with fixed amino acid changes that were reported to reduce body size. Conclusions This study brings new insights into the molecular mechanisms that drove the diversifying evolution of body size in carnivores, and provides new target genes for exploring the mysteries of body size evolution in mammals.

Comparative genomics reveals molecular mechanisms underlying health and reproduction in cryptorchid mammals

“…The fixed amino acid replacements in certain group of mammals might contribute to the explanation underlying a specific phenotype [ 29 ]. Among 5333 proteins and 3,585,819 amino acid positions, only one ascrotal mammal-specific amino acid substitution was identified in Glucagon Like Peptide 2 Receptor (GLP2R).…”

Evolutionary genetics of flipper forelimb and hindlimb loss from limb development-related genes in cetaceans

“…Results of both the two-ratio and free-ratio models were compared with the null model—a one-ratio model that allowed an equal ω ratio for all branches in the phylogeny. When the value of d N or d S in each ω value is less than 0.0002, we considered it as an outlier “n/a” [ 56 ]. The relative goodness-of-fit of the nested models was determined using a likelihood ratio test (LRT) that was performed by comparing twice the difference in ln likelihood scores (2ΔlnL) against a χ 2 distribution, with the number of degrees of freedom corresponding to the difference in number of parameters between the nested models.…”

A phylogenetic review of cancer resistance highlights evolutionary solutions to Peto’s Paradox

“…However, the molecular mechanisms for maintaining large sizes and longevity in large carnivores have not been extensively investigated thus far. Huang et al (2021 ) reported 100 body size-associated genes in carnivores related to cancer control, including tumor suppressors, DNA repair, and immunity. From these genes, 15 cancer-related genes were identified as rapidly evolving in the extremely large lineages, which might protect the animal from cancer invasion: ADGRF2, CABCOCO1, CATSPERG, CCDC146, CPLX4, CTLA4, MAS1, PACSIN1, PHF13, SDR39U1, SLC25A28, TCTE1, TERB1, YTHDC2 and ZBED1 ( Huang et al , 2021 ).…”