Global Circulation Models (GCMs) Simulate the Current Temperature Only If the Shortwave Radiation Anomaly of the 2000s Has Been Omitted

Abstract

The research article of Gillett et al. was published in Nature Climate Change (NCC) in March 2021. The objective of the NCC study was to simulate human-induced forcings to warming by applying 13 CMIP6 (Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6) climate models. NCC did not accept the author’s remarks as a “Matters arising” article. The purpose of this article is to detail the original three remarks and one additional remark: 1) the discrepancy between the graphs and reported numerical values, 2) the forcings of aerosols and clouds, 3) the positive water feedback, and 4) the calculation basis of the Paris agreement. The most important finding is that General Circulation Models (GCMs) used in simulations omit the significant shortwave anomaly from 2001 to 2019, which causes a temperature error of 0.3°C according to climate change physics of Gillett et al. For the year 2019, this error is 0.8°C showing the magnitude of shortwave anomaly impact. The main reason for this error turns out to be the positive water feedback generally applied in climate models. The scientific basis of the Paris climate agreement is faulty for the same reason.

Retracted: Two main temperature periodicities related to planetary and solar activity oscillations

“…Cloudiness changes have a significant impact on shortwave (SW) radiation changes and surface temperature. According to CERES satellite measurements, the SW radiation increased by 1.61 W·m −2 from 2001 to 2019 (Ollila, 2021; Loeb et al ., 2021), which can be compared to the CO 2 radiative forcing of 2.16 W·m −2 from 1750 to 2019 (IPCC, 2021). According to Loeb et al (2018) the correlation between SST and low cloud cover is robust.…”

“…Cloudiness changes have a significant impact on shortwave (SW) radiation changes and surface temperature. According to CERES satellite measurements, the SW radiation increased by 1.61 WÁm −2 from 2001 to 2019 (Ollila, 2021;Loeb et…”