Cytochrome c oxidase (CytcO) is a redox-driven, membranebound proton pump. One of the proton transfer pathways of the enzyme, the D pathway, used for the transfer of both substrate and pumped protons, accommodates a network of hydrogenbonded water molecules that span the distance between an aspartate (Asp 132 ), near the protein surface, and glutamate Glu 286 , which is an internal proton donor to the catalytic site. To investigate how changes in the environment around Glu 286 affect the mechanism of proton transfer through the pathway, we introduced a non-hydrogen-bonding (Ala) or an acidic residue (Asp) at position Ser 197 (S197A or S197D), located ϳ7 Å from Glu 286 . Although Ser 197 is hydrogen-bonded to a water molecule that is part of the D pathway "proton wire," replacement of the Ser by an Ala did not affect the proton transfer rate. In contrast, the S197D mutant CytcO displayed a turnover activity of ϳ35% of that of the wild-type CytcO, and the O 2 reduction reaction was not linked to proton pumping. Instead, a fraction of the substrate protons was taken from the positive ("incorrect") side of the membrane. Furthermore, the pH dependence of the proton transfer rate was altered in the mutant CytcO. The results indicate that there is plasticity in the water coordination of the proton pathway, but alteration of the electrostatic potential within the pathway results in uncoupling of the proton translocation machinery.