This article aims to develop a comprehensive understanding of the comparative performance of a vertical super-thin body (VSTB) field-effect transistor in terms of two device material variations (silicon/Si and germanium/Ge) with the aid of 3-D Senaturus TCAD tool. More importantly, the influence of the inevitable architectural stress (exerted over the thin body by the thick dielectric walls) on the transfer characteristic of the device is also addressed for Si/Ge device. From the perspective of suitability in high-performance circuits, Ge outperforms Si by enhancing on-state current (Ion) by 30.28, 30.29, 29.91, and 26.98 µA at channel length of 10, 20, 30, and 40 nm, respectively, with an improvable deterioration in off-state leakage current, subthreshold swing, and drain-induced-barrier-lowering. Further, a three-dimensional stress analysis reveals that stress increases Ion more in Ge-device compared to its Si-counterpart. As expected, a similar nature is observed for the strain application. Finally, the radio-frequency study shows that although the relative performance of Ge with respect to Si in terms of input capacitance, gate-drain capacitance, and output conductance is inferior, the greater transconductance of Ge than Si lowers intrinsic delay and enhances the peaks of intrinsic gain, unit-gain cut-off frequency, and gain-bandwidth-product.