South Africa produces approximately 7 million tons of sugarcane bagasse annually as an agricultural residue, which is treated as waste and its disposal is known to have negative impacts on the environment. To lessen reliance on petroleum and polymers, consideration is given on use of sugarcane bagasse ash as substitute materials for the development of fillers for rubber and other large-scale commodity polymers. This work reports on the mechanical, physiochemical, and structural properties of sugarcane bagasse ash to define the compatibility with the specific polymers that will pave way to the engineering of composites to utilize the potential benefits of these residue-derived fillers. The structural and morphological properties of the untreated and treated sugarcane bagasse ash were performed using XRD, FTIR, and SEM-EDX, respectively. The obtained results confirmed the successful treatment of the sugarcane bagasse ash. The study was successful in showing that sugarcane bagasse ash as potential filler in rubber polymer matrix is a natural resource of silica, which is sustainable and cost-effective, thus should be harnessed for industrial purposes in South Africa.