Guidelines for psychosocial interventions in dementia care: a European survey and comparison

Abstract

Objective: The effectiveness of psychosocial interventions in treating people with dementia and their carers is increasingly emphasised in the literature. Dementia guidelines should summarise the scientific evidence and best practice that is currently available, therefore, it should include recommendations for psychosocial interventions. The aims of our study were (1) to collate dementia guidelines from countries across Europe and to check whether they included sections about psychosocial interventions, and (2) to compare the methodological quality and the recommendations for specific psychosocial interventions in these guidelines. Methods: The European dementia guidelines were inventoried. The methodological quality of the guideline sections for psychosocial interventions was assessed with the (AGREE) Appraisal of Guidelines Research and Evaluation instrument. The recommendations for specific psychosocial interventions were extracted from each of these guidelines and compared. Results: Guidelines for psychosocial interventions were found in five of 12 countries. Guideline developers, methodological quality and appreciation of available evidence influenced the inclusion of psychosocial interventions in dementia guidelines from Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Spain and the UK. The UK NICE SCIE guideline had the best methodological quality and included the most recommendations for psychosocial interventions. Physical activity and carer interventions were recommended the most across all guidelines. Conclusion: The inclusion of psychosocial interventions in dementia guidelines is limited across Europe. High-quality guidelines that include psychosocial interventions and are kept up to date with the emerging evidence are needed. Throughout Europe, special attention to the implementation of evidencebased psychosocial care is needed in the next few years.

Non-pharmacological interventions as a best practice strategy in people with dementia living in nursing homes. A systematic review

“…It appears that although positive outcomes can be identified when managing behavioral disturbances, it is unclear what causes results to be maintained over time. Recent research has identified the need for strong evidence of their effectiveness [46]. Lawrence et al (2012) showed the benefits of these interventions on QoL and recommend individual psychosocial interventions with a specialist [47].…”

European palliative care guidelines: how well do they meet the needs of people with impaired cognition?

“…If a generic palliative care guideline was not available then raters chose the most widely used cancer care guidelines. This method was successfully used in a review of European guidelines for psychosocial interventions in dementia 11. If members of our network were unable to assist or, a country was not involved in the network, we identified leaders in palliative care through the European Association for Palliative Care (EAPC) or through personal contacts.…”

International Perspectives on Nonpharmacological Best Practices for Dementia Family Caregivers: A Review

“…Programs to increase physicians' knowledge about existing strong evidence based programs would greatly increase the likelihood that they will be used-either alone or alongside other treatments for both patients and caregivers (Vasse et al, 2012). For example, in India, raising awareness of the progression of dementia is sorely needed as physicians lack knowledge about how to assess and treat dementia patients at the various stages of the disease.…”

“…In addition, creating awareness at the general societal level (via media such as radio, television and social network sites) will bring about ways to improve the quality of life for dementia patients and their caregivers. • Third, governments and philanthropic organizations, especially in countries with strong cultural traditions of family care (Vasse et al, 2012) need to make significant investments in development and dissemination of new nonpharmacological treatments and should support research efforts to improve evidence for their effectiveness. Research needs to span basic science, medical, clinical, epidemiological as well as psychological, social and environmental interventions and must include interventions for caregivers.…”