Guns and Butter in China: How Chinese Citizens Respond to Military Spending

Abstract

Militaries are sustained by public money that is diverted away from other domestic ends. How the public react to the “guns-versus-butter” trade-off is thus an important question in understanding the microfoundations of Chinese military power. However, there are few studies on public attitudes towards military spending in China, whose rising power has been a grave concern to many policymakers around the world. We fielded a national online survey to investigate the nature of public support for military spending in China. We find that Chinese citizens support military spending in the abstract, but their support diminishes when considered alongside other domestic spending priorities. We also find that public support for military spending coexists surprisingly with anti-war sentiments and a significant strain of isolationism. In addition, while the conventional wisdom suggests that nationalism moves a state towards bellicosity and war, we find that Chinese citizens with a stronger sense of national pride report stronger anti-war sentiments than other citizens.

Decoding the Thucydides Trap: A Critical Examination of China's Military Capabilities

“…Even if it seems to grow rapidly, military spending is still behind the US in total. Based on official data, China's military expenditure saw a significant rise, growing from 170 billion yuan in 2002 to an impressive 1.04 trillion yuan in 2017 [9] . But compared to the United States, China's military expenditure only constituted 37.65% of that of the US in 2017 [10] .…”

Alternative Futures Following a Great Power War: Volume 1, Scenarios, Findings, and Recommendations

“…Most Chinese citizens were galvanized by the conflict into more actively supporting the CCP, yielding a more nationalistic and bellicose public. 222 The most-hawkish netizens criticized the CCP for failing to seize Taiwan once and for all, and a silent minority criticized the state for not sufficiently safeguarding China's economic prosperity and reducing investments in its social welfare. The handful of dissidents and intellectuals who questioned whether China should stay committed to the reunification of Taiwan were swiftly detained, and some were sentenced to long prison terms as a deterrent to other would-be regime critics.…”

Thinking beyond averages: Quantile regression modelling and military expenditure

“…In China, where the increase for its 2020 defence budget is estimated at 6.6 percent average, the lowest year-by-year increment since 2016, the question is how to divide scarce resources between domestic social programmes and military modernization? In China economic growth has slowed down and the tension between spending priorities have increased (Glaser et al, 2020; Han et al, 2020). Regionally, Chinese military expenditure is also an outlier representing a particular security dilemma.…”