Habitat Partitioning of Four Sympatric Thrush Species at Three Spatial Scales on a Managed Forest in West Virginia

Abstract

Four thrush species are sympatric in the central Appalachians: Veery (Catharus fuscescens), Hermit Thrush (C. guttatus), Wood Thrush (Hylocichla mustelina), and American Robin (Turdus migratorius). The four species often nest near one another, which suggests that habitat partitioning may have developed to minimize past interspecific competition. Our objectives were to determine which specific characteristics of nesting habitat were partitioned among the species and to evaluate the relationship of these characteristics to nest survival. We monitored nests and sampled habitat variables at three spatial scales: nest substrate, nest site, and territory. A multivariate analysis of variance indicated a difference (P < 0.01) in the nest sites of all species and in each pairwise species contrast. An analysis of variance and Fisher’s exact tests detected differences (P < 0.05) among species in 21 of 36 variables measured. Classification tree analysis correctly classified nests by species at a rate better than would be expected at random. Habitat partitioning among the four thrush species occurred at all three scales sampled, with the most important partitioning variables being nest height, distance-to-edge, sapling density, and elevation. Mayfield logistic regression found a positive relationship (P < 0.05) between decreasing nest height and American Robin nest survival. Overall, nest survival was similar among the four thrush species examined, and most of the variables that we measured were unrelated to survival. Partition de l’habitat de quatre espèces sympatriques de grives à trois échelles spatiales dans une forêt aménagée de la Virginie-Occidentale

Nesting success of native and introduced forest birds on the island of Kaua‘i

“…We could not compare our estimates of nest predation to other parts of the world because authors typically used methods of categorizing nest failures that were different from ours (i.e. missing eggs and/or nestlings were classified as depredated; Martin , Powell and Steidl , Robinson et al , Heltzel and Earnst , Dellinger et al ); and, our ability to detect other causes of failure was minimal (i.e. we only confirmed two nests abandoned in each of the egg and nestling stages, and were not able to confirm any weather‐related failures).…”

Invasion by a non‐native ecosystem engineer alters distribution of a native predator

“…Robins have similar habitat requirements to Swainson's thrushes ( Catharus ustulatus ) and hermit thrushes ( Catharus guttatus ), and all three are ground‐ and shrub‐foraging insectivores and frugivores (Dilger, ; Paszkowski, ). However, research on hermit thrushes and American robins when sympatric suggests that habitat partitioning occurs between the two species possibly because of competitive interactions (Dellinger et al ., ). Changes in predator abundance or distribution as a result of increases in one prey species can also affect other prey through apparent competition (Carlsson et al ., ), but it is unclear whether this possibility is likely to apply to robin and earthworm populations.…”

Avian Habitat Use in a Chronosequence of Bottomland Hardwood Forest-Restoration Sites

“…One example is post-fledging Wood Thrushes, which occupied early successional oak-Carya (hickory) forests rather than mature forests where adults were typically found (Anders et al 1998). Some additional species, such as the Red-winged Blackbird, American Robin, Northern Cardinal, and White-throated Sparrow, had unusual indicators in their models but are considered to be generalist species (Blackwell and Dolbeer 2001, Dellinger et al 2007, Kilgo et al 1998, Rousseau et al 2012, Whittaker and Marzluff 2009. Therefore, they are less responsive to habitat structure and do not necessarily produce predictive models indicative of their typical preference (Carrara et al 2015, Hinsley et al 2009, Julliard et al 2006.…”