Has Germany “Fallen Out of Love” with Europe? The Eurozone Crisis and the “Normalization” of Germany's European Identity

Abstract

The European Union has been in its biggest ever crisis since the onset of the Greek sovereign debt crisis in 2010. Beyond the political and economic dimensions, the crisis has also sparked discussions about Germany's European identity. Some scholars have argued that Germany's behavior in the crisis signals a continuation of the process of "normalization" of its European identity toward a stronger articulation of national identity and interests, that it has "fallen out of love" with Europe. This article will seek to reassess these claims, drawing on detailed analysis of political and media discourse in Germany-from political speeches through to both broadsheet and tabloid newspapers. It will argue that the crisis is understood broadly as a European crisis in Germany, where the original values of European integration are at stake. Furthermore, the crisis is debated through the lens of European solidarity, albeit with a particular German flavor of solidarity that draws on the economic tradition of ordoliberalism. Rather than strengthening expressions of national identity, this has resulted in the emergence of a new northern European identity in contrast to Greece or "southern Europe."

Farewell Britannia? ‘Issue Capture’ and the Politics of David Cameron's 2013 EU Referendum Pledge

“…Cameron's best hope may, therefore, rest on strong economic recovery in the eurozone which would accord – in the scheduled German federal election year of 2017 – Merkel more room for manoeuvre. But even that hope glazes over the fact that Germany's EU policy has become much less generous and idealistic and driven more by hard‐headed calculations of the national interest (Bulmer and Paterson, ; Galpin, ).…”

What does it Mean to be European? How Identity Content Shapes Adolescents’ Views

“…In the present study, we examined European identity content in two German federal states, Thuringia and North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW). Germany is an interesting country to study European identity since a European identity was promoted as an alternative to a nationalistic German identity after WWII (Galpin, 2015). Following social identity theory, a person that categorizes themself as a group member can do so with multiple groups at the same time, if the identity contents are compatible (e.g., Spanish and European identity, Medrano & Gutiérrez, 2001).…”

The European Debt Crisis and the Quest for European Solidarity

“…As the crisis required collective problem-solving strategies that were not in place at its breakout, the European debt crisis soon turned into a political crisis of substantial magnitude. This debate circled around the pivotal question of if and to what degree EU member states should help each other in times of crisis and thereby ultimately around the question of European solidarity (Galpin, 2015(Galpin, , 2017Verhaegen, 2018). Indeed, 'since 2010 […] the Eurozone crisis has forced member states to make some steps in the exercise of inter-state solidarity that were unimaginable just some years ago' (Fernandes & Rubio, 2012, p. 19).…”