Isolation between academic fields is an unfortunate reality in higher education and teacher education. Whereas current educational reforms invoke a need to collaborate, faculty are often unsure of how to design collaborative experiences. Research argues for the use of co-teaching to engage teacher candidates in beneficial learning experiences where instructors model the collaborative practices desired in those candidates. Additionally, the use of co-teaching in rural settings is shown to address some of the challenges associated with rural teacher preparation. With the hesitancy of many in higher education to engage in co-teaching in teacher preparation, it is crucial that those who do co-teach share the design, implementation, and perceptions of the process with others. This article presents the design, implementation, and reflections of students and teacher preparation faculty: one content methods instructor and one content literacy instructor. The authors present the hassles and hopes of using co-teaching in teacher preparation in rural regions to enhance course content and collaboration among teacher candidates.