Nephrolithiasis is a common condition affecting nearly 1 in 11 Americans. The most common type of stone, calcium oxalate is known to form on a calcium phosphate deposit on the renal papilla known as Randall's plaque. Novel imaging techniques have identified distinct regions of biomineralization not just at the tip, but throughout the renal papilla. The classic understanding of Randall's plaque formation is reformulated using correlative imaging techniques. This study establishes a stepwise progression of anatomically-specific biomineralization events including, 1) proximal intratubular mineralization within the renal pyramid; 2) interstitial Randall's plaque near the tip of the papilla; 3) emerging plaque (stems); and, 4) the body of heterogeneous stones, and provides insights into the need for plausible site-specific therapeutic intervention.