Decision-making processes, like all traits of an organism, are shaped by evolution; they thus carry a signature of the selection pressures associated with choice behaviors. The way sexual communication signals are integrated during courtship likely reflects the costs and benefits associated with mate choice. Here, we study the evaluation of male song by females during acoustic courtship in grasshoppers. Using playback experiments and computational modeling we find that information of different valence (attractive vs. nonattractive) is weighted asymmetrically: while information associated with nonattractive features has large weight, attractive features add little to the decision to mate. Accordingly, nonattractive features effectively veto female responses. Because attractive features have so little weight, the model suggests that female responses are frequently driven by integration noise. Asymmetrical weighting of negative and positive information may reflect the fitness costs associated with mating with a nonattractive over an attractive singer, which are also highly asymmetrical. In addition, nonattractive cues tend to be more salient and therefore more reliable. Hence, information provided by them should be weighted more heavily. Our findings suggest that characterizing the integration of sensory information during a natural behavior has the potential to provide valuable insights into the selective pressures shaping decision-making during evolution.O ne crucial decision in the lifetime of an animal is the decision with whom to mate. The males of many animals have evolved elaborate traits to attract females (1). These traits often involve the production of calling or courtship songs (2-4). Females base their decision to engage in courtship and to mate on the properties of these signals. Though many different factors drive and constrain the evolution of behavioral decisions in general (5, 6), the way information is integrated in the context of mate selection may reflect the fitness costs and benefits associated with mate choice. These costs depend on the mating system, e.g., the abundance of potential mating partners, the likelihood and costs of multiple matings, direct benefits of mating, and the costs of assessing a potential mate (7-10).Here, we investigate the implementation of a decision-making strategy by studying the integration of song features during courtship in grasshoppers. Acoustic courtship in the species Chorthippus biguttulus involves bidirectional communication. Males produce calling songs consisting of a sequence of simple stereotyped subunits-30-50 syllable-pause pairs. The female waits until the end of this song and indicates her readiness to further engage in a courtship ritual by producing a response song that allows the male to localize and approach the female (11) (Fig. 1A). This phase of courtship constitutes a first, important preselection step before females make their final assessment of an approaching mating partner. Not responding or responding to a male calling from a distance i...