Zintl phases with complex crystal structures have been studied as promising candidate materials for thermoelectric (TE) applications. Here, we report the syntheses of the family of rare-earth metal Zintl phases with the general formula Ca 4−x RE x Sb 3 (x ≈ 1; RE = La−Nd, Sm, Gd−Tm, Lu). The structural elucidation is based on refinements of single-crystal X-ray diffraction data for 12 unique chemical compositions. The cubic structure is confirmed as belonging to the anti-Th 3 P 4 structure type (space group I4̅ 3d, no. 220, Z = 4), where the Ca and RE atoms share the same atomic site with ca. 75 and 25% occupancies, respectively. Such crystallographic disordering of divalent Ca and trivalent RE atoms in the structure provides a pathway to intricate bonding. The latter, together with the presence of heavy elements such as Sb and the lanthanides, are expected to enhance the scattering probability of phonons, thereby leading to low thermal conductivity κ comparable to that of the ordered RE 4 Sb 3 . The drive of the hypothetical parent compound Ca 4 Sb 3 to be stabilized by alloying with rare-earth metals can be understood following the Zintl−Klemm concept, as the resultant formula may be rationalized as (Ca 2+ ) 3 RE 3+ (Sb 3− ) 3 , indicating the realization of closed-shell electronic configurations for all elements. This notion is confirmed by electronic structure calculations, which reveal narrow bandgaps E g = 0.77 and 0.53 eV for Ca 3 LaSb 3 and Ca 3 LuSb 3 , respectively. In addition, the incorporation of RE atoms into the structure drives the phase into a state of a degenerate semiconductor with dominant hole charge carriers.