To examine the survival histories and potential extirpation factors of five large marsupial carnivores that once occurred on three large Australian continental shelf islands to inform predator restoration efforts to Kangaroo Island. Location Kangaroo Island, King Island and Flinders Island-located on the continental shelf off the southern coastline of the Australian mainland. Methods A review of historical accounts and fossil evidence. Primary source of marsupial carnivore records was the National Library of Australia's online newspaper digitisation website, Trove, covering the period 1803-1954. Additional sources included books and diaries written by explorers, visitors or early settlers; relevant natural history, agriculture and science journals and zoological books; and fossil specimens and museum records of marsupial carnivores. Results The pattern of species persistence and extirpation on Kangaroo Island parallels those observed on King and Flinders Islands. Fossil data supports the terminal Pleistocene-early Holocene extinction of the thylacine (Thylacinus cynocephalus) from Kangaroo Island and the Tasmanian devil (Sarcophilus harrisii) from both Kangaroo and Flinders Islands. Though eastern quoll (Dasyurus viverrinus) fossils have been found on Kangaroo and Flinders Islands, and D. geoffroii on Kangaroo Island, contemporary evidence for their post-European persistence is unclear. In contrast, fossil, museum and anecdotal data supports the presence of the spotted-tailed quoll (Dasyurus maculatus) on all three islands and, contrary to established knowledge, its post-European persistence on Kangaroo Island. Main Conclusions 3 The loss of T. cynocephalus, S. harrisii, D. geoffroii and D. viverrinus appear to be commensurate with late to terminal Pleistocene-early Holocene climate change and associated changes in vegetation communities. In contrast, anthropogenic persecution of D. maculatus appears to be the principal cause of its post-European extirpation. We recommend D. maculatus as a suitable candidate marsupial carnivore for reintroduction to Kangaroo Island, and possibly King and Flinders Islands.