‘How can we help when she won't tell us what's wrong?’ Professionals working with South Asian women who have experienced sexual abuse

Abstract

In this paper, we explore some of the issues facing professionals in the UK currently involved in providing services for South Asian women who have experienced sexual abuse. The study describes part of a wider Economic and Social Research Council funded project, based upon interviews and focus groups with both professionals and women survivors of sexual abuse. Drawing on semistructured interviews and two focus groups with 37 professionals including psychological therapists, refuge and project workers, from a range of organisations, our aim in this paper is to provide a discursive analysis of some of the key dilemmas faced by professionals working with sexual abuse in South Asian communities by exploring two central interpretive repertoires: 'culture not self' and 'symptom talk as solution'. The analysis indicates that professionals face a series of dilemmas when working with South Asian women survivors. They highlight the tension between individualised models of personhood in many psychological therapies and the challenge to these by South Asian communities who hold a more relational view of the person. One of the strategies used by professionals to work with the tensions between 'culture' and the 'reality' of the survivor's pain was the translation of women's distress into symptoms of mental disorder. However, the consequences of this intervention raised some serious issues, including further pathologisation and stigma. The implications of these findings will be discussed in terms of how to understand the experiences of South Asian women from a more socially grounded perspective and to explore the issues they face in accessing and receiving appropriate services to deal with the aftermath of sexually abusive experiences.

Juvenile prostitution and community rehabilitation: an exploratory analysis of beliefs and values

“…The therapeutic interventions offered by the programme are mostly unstructured, and focus on emotions and the past. Engagement in therapy can, however, be difficult for some individuals who have experienced sexual abuse (Reavey, Ahmed, & Majumdar, 2006). Such interventions also often require a long-term commitment from participants, which is seldom possible due to the frequency with which many relapse and return to the street.…”

Talking Therapy Services for Adult Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse (CSA) in Scotland: Perspectives of Service Users and Professionals

“…Existing evidence suggests that different approaches may have different contributions for different stages of recovery (Edmond, Sloan, & McCarty, 2004;Feinauer, Bringham, & Provo, 1989;Nelson & Phillips, 2001). Also, it appears that survivors find disclosure beneficial if enquiries are made sensitively (McGregor et al, 2006;Nelson & Phillips, 2001;Reavey, Ahmed, & Majumdar, 2006;Schachter et al, 2004).…”

Gay men’s identity work and the social construction of discrimination

“…Collective action is partly dependent on persuading communities that there is an injustice that must be addressed: colleagues who do advocacy work for minority groups report that a significant part of their work is spent persuading service users that their experiences are not part of 'normal life' but evidence of discrimination (Reavey, Ahmed, & Majumdar, 2006). Our analysis can help us to understand the psychological barriers to talking about discrimination, and the tools by which practitioners and advocates can faciliate the transformation of problematic experiences from 'not discrimination' into 'discrimination'.…”