How measurements affected by medication use are reported and handled in observational research: A literature review

Abstract

In epidemiological research, measurements affected by medication, for example, blood pressure lowered by antihypertensives, are common. Different ways of handling medication are required depending on the research questions and whether the affected measurement is the exposure, the outcome, or a confounder.This study aimed to review handling of medication use in observational research.Methods: PubMed was searched for etiological studies published between 2015 and 2019 in 15 high-ranked journals from cardiology, diabetes, and epidemiology.We selected studies that analyzed blood pressure, glucose, or lipid measurements (whether exposure, outcome or confounder) by linear or logistic regression.Two reviewers independently recorded how medication use was handled and assessed whether the methods used were in accordance with the research aim.We reported the methods used per variable category (exposure, outcome, confounder).Results: A total of 127 articles were included. Most studies did not perform any method to account for medication use (exposure 58%, outcome 53%, and confounder 45%). Restriction (exposure 22%, outcome 23%, and confounders 10%), or adjusting for medication use using a binary indicator were also used frequently (exposure: 18%, outcome: 19%, confounder: 45%). No advanced methods were applied. In 60% of studies, the methods' validity could not be judged due to ambiguous reporting of the research aim. Invalid approaches were used in 28% of the studies, mostly when the affected variable was the outcome (36%). Conclusion:Many studies ambiguously stated the research aim and used invalid methods to handle medication use. Researchers should consider a valid methodological approach based on their research question.

Tying research question and analytical strategy when variables are affected by medication use

“…9 As practical guidance, several authors 4,[10][11][12] discussed statistical methods that could be used when measurements are affected by medication use. However, our recent review of the handling of medication use in medical papers 13 demonstrated that a majority of studies featured vaguely formulated research questions and unclear research aims. Invalid methods were often used and a justification for the chosen method was rarely given.…”