Hybridization Hotspots at Bat Swarming Sites

Abstract

During late summer and early autumn in temperate zones of the Northern Hemisphere, thousands of bats gather at caves, mainly for the purpose of mating. We demonstrated that this swarming behavior most probably leads not only to breeding among bats of the same species but also interbreeding between different species. Using 14 nuclear microsatellites and three different methods (the Bayesian assignment approaches of STRUCTURE and NEWHYBRIDS and a principal coordinate analysis of pairwise genetic distances), we analyzed 375 individuals belonging to three species of whiskered bats (genus Myotis) at swarming sites across their sympatric range in southern Poland. The overall hybridization rate varied from 3.2 to 7.2%. At the species level, depending on the method used, these values ranged from 2.1–4.6% in M. mystacinus and 3.0–3.7% in M. brandtii to 6.5–30.4% in M. alcathoe. Hybrids occurred in about half of the caves we studied. In all three species, the sex ratio of hybrids was biased towards males but the observed differences did not differ statistically from those noted at the population level. In our opinion, factors leading to the formation of these admixed individuals and their relatively high frequency are: i) swarming behaviour at swarming sites, where high numbers of bats belonging to several species meet; ii) male-biased sex ratio during the swarming period; iii) the fact that all these bats are generally polygynous. The highly different population sizes of different species at swarming sites may also play some role. Swarming sites may represent unique hybrid hotspots, which, as there are at least 2,000 caves in the Polish Carpathians alone, may occur on a massive scale not previously observed for any group of mammal species in the wild. Evidently, these sites should be treated as focal points for the conservation of biodiversity and evolutionary processes.

Speciation processes in putative island endemic sister bat species: false impressions from mitochondrial DNA and microsatellite data

“…; Bogdanowicz et al . ). In our study, however, sequencing and analyses of the respective M. recondita microsatellite flanking regions—which are expected to evolve more slowly than their adjacent microsatellite motifs (Estoup et al .…”

Geographic variation in hybridization and ecological differentiation between three syntopic, morphologically similar species of montane lizards

“…) and bats (Bogdanowicz et al . ). Accordingly, we predicted that hybridization should be highest between the recently diverged sister species P. cryodroma and P. entrecasteauxii and indeed, this was the case at BHP and HT.…”

“…While studies on hybrid systems generally focus on two species and/or a single point of contact (but see Bogdanowicz et al . ; Fisch et al . ; Marino et al .…”

SimHyb: a simulation software for the study of the evolution of hybridizing populations. Application to Quercus ilex and Q. suber suggests hybridization could be underestimated

“…This approach was applied by Burgarella et al (2009) in sympatric Q. ilex -Q. suber populations, estimating a current introgression rate of <2%. Later on, this procedure has been applied in studies for many other species, including animals (Neaves et al 2010, Bogdanowicz et al 2012, Malde et al 2017.…”