Synthetically modified proteins, such as gelatin methacryloyl (GelMA), are growing in popularity for bioprinting and biofabrication. GelMA is a photocurable macromer that can rapidly form hydrogels, while also presenting bioactive peptide sequences for cellular adhesion and proliferation. The mechanical properties of GelMA are highly tunable by modifying the degree of substitution via synthesis conditions, though the effects of source material and thermal gelation have not been comprehensively characterized for lower concentration gels. Herein, the effects of animal source and processing sequence are investigated on scaffold mechanical properties. Hydrogels of 4–6 wt% are characterized. Depending on the temperature at crosslinking, the storage moduli for GelMA derived from pigs, cows, and cold‐water fish range from 723 to 7340 Pa, 516 to 3484 Pa, and 294 to 464 Pa, respectively. The maximum storage moduli are achieved only by coordinated physical gelation and chemical crosslinking. In this method, the classic thermo‐reversible gelation of gelatin occurs when GelMA is cooled below a thermal transition temperature, which is subsequently “locked in” by chemical crosslinking via photocuring. The effects of coordinated physical gelation and chemical crosslinking are demonstrated by precise photopatterning of cell‐laden microstructures, inducing different cellular behavior depending on the selected mechanical properties of GelMA.