Illegal Gold Mining and Violence in Colombia

Abstract

The increase in the international price of commodities after the international financial crisis in 2008 produced a gold rush in the Colombian economy, making legal and illegal mining a very profitable and attractive business. The increase in the illegal exploitation of metals like gold has exacerbated violence in municipalities with an abundance of such minerals. Gold is believed to be a new engine in the Colombian conflict. This paper documents the phenomenon and quantifies the causal impact that the gold boom has had on indicators of violence such as homicides, forced displacement and massacres. We use the location of national parks, indigenous reserves and geochemical anomalies associated with the presence of gold mines as instruments for illegal mining in order to disentangle the causal effect of illegal mining on violence. By law, it is very difficult to get licenses for the extraction of gold in parks and indigenous reserves, and this might be a factor increasing the prevalence of illegal mining activities in municipalities with these features. In order to have time variation in our instruments, we interact geographical features associated with the presence of gold and illegal gold mining (which vary only at the municipal level) with the international price of gold. Our estimates indicate that the rise of illegal gold mining has caused a statistically significant increase in violence, as measured with the homicide rate and the victims of massacres. However, we do not find a significant causal effect of illegal gold mining on forced displacement. Our interpretation is that the increase in the profitability of illegal mining activities has sparked a dispute over territorial control between illegal armed groups in order to monopolize the extraction of the precious minerals. Nevertheless, illegal mining is a labor intensive activity, and this may have counteracted the incentives of illegal armed groups to displace local populations from their land.

Conflict-Induced Poverty: Evidence from Colombia

“…The hypothesis that armed groups try to protect their sources of finance violently is consistent with the results of Idrobo et al (2013), and Abadie et al (2013). 12 There are four main variables for the MPI that are not included in the 1993 Census: i) access to childcare services, ii) affiliation to a pension fund (proxy of formality), iii) health insurance coverage, and iv) access to health services in case of need.…”

Mining as the “Locomotive” of the Colombian Economy: It’s Real Cost

“…However, few academic studies have examined in detail the side effects of the recent mining boom (legal and illegal) on the levels of violence. A recent social science paper that quantified the causal impact of the gold boom on indicators of violence such as homicides, forced displacements and massacres, found that the recent gold rush has become a new driving force in territorial conflicts and has exacerbated violence in gang-controlled (but not corporation-controlled) gold mining areas [13]. In light of this situation and the lack of an updated mining census, the Colombian Comptroller General (Contraloria de la República), which is a monitoring agency, has called for a moratorium or "standby" to granting any new mining concessions until the sector can be properly managed and administered to benefit Colombia [6].…”

Gold, power, protest: Digital and social media and protests against large-scale mining projects in Colombia

“…Demonstrating a statistically significant increase in homicides and massacres in municipalities with gold production, Idrobo et al (2014) believe that gold is 'the new engine in the Colombian conflict ' (p. 4).…”