2Mitochondrial and plastid genomes in land plants exhibit some of the slowest rates of sequence 3 evolution observed in any eukaryotic genome, suggesting an exceptional ability to prevent or correct 4 mutations. However, the mechanisms responsible for this extreme fidelity remain unclear. We tested 5 seven candidate genes involved in cytoplasmic DNA replication, recombination, and repair (POLIA, 6 POLIB, MSH1, RECA3, UNG, FPG, and OGG1) for effects on mutation rates in the model 7 angiosperm Arabidopsis thaliana by applying a highly accurate DNA sequencing technique (duplex 8 sequencing) that can detect newly arisen mitochondrial and plastid mutations still at low 9 heteroplasmic frequencies. We find that disrupting MSH1 (but not the other candidate genes) leads 10 to massive increases in the frequency of point mutations and small indels and changes to the 11 mutation spectrum in mitochondrial and plastid DNA. We also used droplet digital PCR to show 12 transmission of de novo heteroplasmies across generations in msh1 mutants, confirming a 13 contribution to heritable mutation rates. This dual-targeted gene is part of an enigmatic lineage within 14 the mutS mismatch repair family that we find is also present outside of green plants in multiple 15 eukaryotic groups (stramenopiles, alveolates, haptophytes, and cryptomonads), as well as certain 16 bacteria and viruses. MSH1 has previously been shown to limit ectopic recombination in plant 17 cytoplasmic genomes. Our results point to a broader role in recognition and correction of errors in 18 plant mitochondrial and plastid DNA sequence, leading to greatly suppressed mutation rates 19 perhaps via initiation of double-stranded breaks and repair pathways based on faithful homologous 20 recombination.It has been apparent for more than 30 years that rates of nucleotide substitution in plant 24 mitochondrial and plastid genomes are unusually low (1,2). In angiosperms, mitochondrial and 25 plastid genomes have synonymous substitution rates that are on average approximately 16-fold and 26 5-fold slower than the nucleus, respectively (3). The fact that these low rates are evident even at 27 sites that are subject to relatively small amounts of purifying selection (4, 5) suggests that they are 28 the result of very low underlying mutation rates -a surprising observation especially when 29 contrasted with the rapid accumulation of mitochondrial mutations in many eukaryotic lineages (6,7).
30Although the genetic mechanisms that enable plants to achieve such faithful replication and 31 transmission of cytoplasmic DNA sequences have not been determined, a number of hypotheses 32 can be envisioned. One possibility is that the DNA polymerases responsible for replicating 33 mitochondrial and plastid DNA (8) might have unusually high fidelity. However, in vitro assays with 34 the two partially redundant bacterial-like organellar DNA polymerases in Arabidopsis thaliana, PolIA
35(At1g50840) and PolIB (At3g20540), have indicated that they are highly error-prone (9), with 36 misincorpo...