Despite the existence of three competing reactions for propargyloxyoxindoles, we report a chemoselectivity switch between enantioselective propargyl [2,3]‐Wittig rearrangement and Conia‐ene‐type reactions, with suppression of the [1,2]‐Wittig‐type rearrangement. Using C1‐symmetric imidazolidine‐pyrroloimidazolone pyridine as the ligand and Ni(acac)2 as the Lewis acid, diverse 3‐hydroxy 3‐substituted oxindoles containing allenyl groups were obtained in up to 98% yield and 99% ee via asymmetric propargyl [2,3]‐Wittig rearrangement. In the presence of AgOTf‐Duanphos, chiral spiro dihydrofuran oxindoles were given in up to 98% yield and 91% ee through a Conia‐ene‐type reaction.