Reactions of group 4 metallocene sources with 2-substituted pyridines were investigated to evaluate their coordination type between innocent and reductive dearomatisation as well as to probe the possibility for couplings. A dependence on the cyclopentadienyl ligands (Cp, Cp*), the metals (Ti, Zr), and the substrates (2-phenyl-, 2-acetyl-, and 2-iminopyridine) was observed. While 2-phenylpyridine is barely reactive, 2-acetylpyridine reacts vigorously with the Cp-substituted complexes and selectively with their Cp* analogues. With 2-iminopyridine, in all cases selective reactions were observed. In the isolated [Cp Ti], [Cp Zr], and [Cp* Zr] compounds the substrate coordinates by its pyridyl ring and the unsaturated side-chain. Subsequently, the pyridine was dearomatised, which is most pronounced in the [Cp* Zr] compounds. Using [Cp* Ti] leads to the unexpected paramagnetic complexes [Cp* Ti (N,O-acpy)] and [Cp* Ti (N,N'-impy)]. This highlights the non-innocent character of the pyridyl substrates.