The skin hosts a variety of dendritic cells (DCs) which act as professional antigen presenting cells (APC) to control cutaneous immunity. Langerhans cells (LCs) are the only DC subset in healthy epidermis. However, due to the complexity of the skin DC network, their relative contribution to either immune activation or immune tolerance is still not entirely understood. To specifically study function of LCs in vivo, without altering the DC subset composition in the skin, we have generated transgenic mouse models for tamoxifen- (TAM) inducible de-novo expression of antigens in LCs but no other langerin+ DCs. Therefore, this system allows for LC-restricted antigen presentation to T cells. Presentation of non-secreted ovalbumin (GFPOVA) by steady-state LCs resulted in transient activation of endogenous cytotoxic T cells (CTL) in transgenic mice. However, when these mice were challenged with OVA by gene gun (GG) immunization in the contraction phase of the primary CTL response they did not respond with a recall of CTL memory but, instead, with robust antigen-specific CTL tolerance. We found regulatory T cells (Tregs) enriched in the skin of tolerized mice, and depletion of Tregs or adoptive experiments revealed that Tregs were critically involved in CTL tolerance. By contrast, when OVA was presented by activated LCs, a recallable CTL memory response developed in transgenic mice. Thus, neoantigen presentation by epidermal LCs results in, either, robust CTL tolerance or CTL memory, and this decision-making depends on the activation state of the presenting LCs.