Uveal and cutaneous melanomas differ in tumor biology, immunophenotypes and the demographic correlates of their occurrence. As a means to examine the possibility of some shared etiologic factors, we wished to learn if the 2 cancers occurred in the same individual more often than would be expected by chance. Data from the Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) program from 1973-1998 were utilized for this purpose. The number of persons who went on to develop a second melanoma was compared to that expected based on the incidence of each type of melanoma in the general population, after adjusting for age, sex, calendar year and residence. Given an initial cutaneous melanoma, there was a 10-fold increased risk of developing a second cutaneous melanoma (95% confidence interval [CI] ؍ 9.4 -10.6). Persons with uveal melanoma went on to develop cutaneous melanoma 4.6 times (95% CI ؍ 2.9 -6.8) more often than the population at large. In contrast, persons with cutaneous melanoma were not subsequently diagnosed with uveal melanoma at an appreciably elevated rate (standardized incidence ratio [SIR] ؍ 1.4; 95% CI ؍ 0.5-3.0). While these data offer some support for the hypothesis that uveal and cutaneous melanomas have 1 or more etiologies in common, the lack of symmetry in the pattern of second uveal and second cutaneous melanomas remains unexplained. © 2002 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Key words: uveal melanoma; cutaneous melanoma; SEER; second cancerDespite originating from a common precursor cell, uveal melanomas (UMs, primary melanomas of the iris, ciliary body and choroid) and cutaneous melanomas (CMs) exhibit several notable differences. Although both are relatively uncommon, UM occurs far less frequently. 1 In addition, incidence and mortality rates of UM have been stable in worldwide registries from 1950 -1980, while rates of CM have increased during that same time period. 2 Although risk factors such as skin color and eye color may be shared, 3-6 the effect of environmental risk factors such as sunlight appears to be different. 1,4,[7][8][9] Biologically, UMs metastasize hematogenously, involving the liver most frequently, 10 while CMs most often involve the regional lymph nodes. 11 Recent immunolabeling studies 12,13 have shown that common melanoma-associated antigens are expressed differently in the 2 cancers.As another means of evaluating the possibility of shared etiologic factors between UM and CM, we sought to learn whether the two tumors occurred in the same person more frequently than would be expected by chance. The Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) cancer registry collects data on incidence, survival and subsequent primary cancers. We utilized this database to examine the incidence of UM and CM as second primary cancers. We also report on the incidence of melanomas of the conjunctiva separately: Although these are ocular melanomas, their histologic and immunocytochemical characteristics are more similar to CM than to UM. 14
MATERIAL AND METHODSSince 1973, the National Cancer Institu...