Impact Analysis of the Interobserver Variability in CBCT-Based Soft-Tissue Matching using TCP/NTCP Models for Prostate Cancer Radiotherapy

Abstract

Background: Prostate alignment is subject to interobserver variability in cone-beam CT (CBCT)-based soft-tissue matching. This study aims to analyze the impact of interobserver variability in CBCT-based soft-tissue matching for prostate cancer radiotherapy.Methods: Retrospective data, consisting of 156 CBCT images from twelve patients with intermediate- or high-risk prostate cancer were analyzed in this study. To simulate interobserver variability, couch shifts of 2 mm relative to the resulting patient position of prostate alignment were assumed as potential patient positions (27 possibilities). For each CBCT, the doses of the potential patient positions were recalculated using deformable image registration-based synthetic CT. The impact of the simulated interobserver variability was evaluated using tumor control probabilities (TCPs) and normal tissue complication probabilities (NTCPs).Results: No significant differences in TCPs were found between prostate alignment and potential patient positions (0.944 ± 0.003 vs 0.945 ± 0.003, P = 0.117). The average NTCPs of the rectum ranged from 5.16 (%) to 7.29 (%) among the potential patient positions and were highly influenced by the couch shift in anterior-posterior direction. In contrast, the average NTCPs of the bladder ranged from 0.75 (%) to 1.12 (%) among the potential patient positions and were relatively negligible.Conclusions: The NTCPs of the rectum, rather than the TCPs of the target, were highly influenced by the interobserver variability in CBCT-based soft-tissue matching. This study provides a theoretical explanation for daily CBCT-based image guidance and the prostate-rectum interface matching procedure.Trial registration: Not applicable.