Impact of Hospital “Best Practice” Mandates on Prescription Opioid Dispensing After an Emergency Department Visit

Abstract

Objective Washington State mandated seven hospital “best practices” in July 2012, several of which may affect ED opioid prescribing and provide a policy template for addressing the opioid prescription epidemic. We tested the hypothesis that the mandates would reduce opioid dispensing after an ED visit. We further assessed for a selective effect in patients with prior risky or chronic opioid use. Methods We performed a retrospective, observational analysis of ED visits by Medicaid fee-for service beneficiaries in Washington State, between July 1, 2011 to June 30, 2013. We used an interrupted time series design to control for temporal trends and patient characteristics. The primary outcome was any opioid dispensing within 3 days after an ED visit. The secondary outcome was total morphine milligram equivalents (MMEs) dispensed within 3 days. Results We analyzed 266,614 ED visits. Mandates were associated with a small reduction in opioid dispensing after an ED visit (−1.5%, 95%CI: −2.8% to −0.15%). The mandates were associated with decreased opioid dispensing in 42,496 ED visits by patients with prior risky opioid use behavior (−4.7%, 95%CI: −7.1% to −2.3%) and in 20,238 visits by patients with chronic opioid use (−3.6%, 95%CI: −5.6% to −1.7%). Mandates were not associated with reductions in MMEs per dispense in the overall cohort or in either subgroup. Conclusions Washington state “best practice” mandates were associated with small but non-selective reductions in opioid prescribing rates. States should focus on alternative policies to further reduce opioid dispensing in subgroups of high risk and chronic users.

Analgesic prescribing trends in a national sample of older veterans with osteoarthritis: 2012-2017

“…Other studies have demonstrated that educational programs, state monitoring programs, and a "Best practices initiative" continue to be effective in reducing opioid prescribing. [16] Our findings mirrored those of Lin et al, 2017 [9] using VHA data demonstrating the increase and subsequent decrease in opioid prescribing prepost the 2013 OSI respectively.…”

Reduction of Parenteral Opioid Use in Community Emergency Departments Following Implementation of Treatment Guidelines

“…There is a need to better understand the effectiveness of treatment guidelines, independent of other interventions, to inform future policies, care improvement efforts, and research . Moreover, the effects of general guidelines on specific ED sub populations (e.g., patients with chronic opioid use or new fracture) is not known.…”

Effect on Morphine Requirement of Early Administration of Oral Acetaminophen vs. Acetaminophen/Tramadol Combination in Acute Pain

“…Accordingly, opioid‐sparing approaches that achieve adequate pain control in ED patients are needed. Several methods and guidelines have been proposed to decrease opioid use in ED patients . Our study demonstrates that a simple action based on the early prescription of the tramadol/acetaminophen combination was associated with a decrease in the amount of opioid prescriptions written by emergency physicians.…”