Impact of Medical TV Shows on Preprocedural Fear of Surgical In-House Patients

Abstract

Background and Hypotheses: The growing number of medical television series and the increasing amount of time people spend watching TV will have an influence on what they expect from their treatment in a hospital. We suspect that reality as presented in the media and the actual reality of hospitals are not always conceived of as two different worlds. Many medical TV shows present dramatic, life-threatening operations much more often than they occur in reality. Patients who frequently watch such shows might be induced to believe that even routine operations are often dangerous, which could result in higher levels of fear before such an operation. We suspect then that there is a significant relation between preoperative levels of fear and TV viewing habits. Methods: A standardized questionnaire was used to interview 162 in-house patients who had come to the hospital for an elective standard operation in a German hospital. They were interviewed 1-2 days prior to operation and shortly before discharge from hospital. The questions aimed at their social situation, their TV viewing habits with special consideration of medical TV shows, and the patients' preprocedural fear. Results: The links between levels of education, age, and gender on the one hand, and viewing habits on the other, which have been shown in cultivation research, are supported by our findings. Approximately 50% reported a relevant anxiety level above 4 (on a scale of 0-10). There is a significant association between levels of fear and TV viewing habits. Thirteen subjects (8%) indicated that they suffered the highest imaginable degree of fear, all of them frequent watchers of medical TV shows. Frequent viewers of medical TV shows were definitely more scared than all other patients (p = 0.039). The preoperative level of fear was highest in the age group of under 40 years and significantly lower (p = 0.0042) in the age group of over 70 years. Conclusion: The assumed effects of cultivation with in-house patients caused by watching TV series could be shown to be statistically significant. Watching medical TV shows increases the patients' preoperative fear.

Role of information and preparation for improvement of pediatric perioperative care

“…Proper preparation helps children to establish trust and safety by learning and understanding about procedures and generate accurate expectations of what will be experienced 6 . This is important since children of today may have a distorted picture of sickness and hospitalization 40 . Providing children with reality‐based information help them regulate their expectations and alleviate their fears 6 .…”

“…6 This is important since children of today may have a distorted picture of sickness and hospitalization. 40 Providing children with reality-based information help them regulate their expectations and alleviate their fears. 6 Preparation is also important to increase children's cooperation and reduce short-term and long-term negative behavioral consequences, to help children gain trust and confidence in healthcare providers, to deal with what has happened and to better cope with future medical care and treatment.…”

Was das Unterhaltungsfernsehen zur Vermittlung von medizinischem Wissen an Studierende und Laien beitragen kann – Sensibilisierung für seltene Erkrankungen

“…Er verhält sich ethisch betrachtet oft fragwürdig und sein Fehlverhalten hätte durchaus juristische Konsequenzen. Generell neigen wahrscheinlich alle TV-Formate aus dem Medizinumfeld zu unrealistischen Darstellungen des Klinikalltags, was Witzel et al an einem Kollektiv chirurgischer Patienten nachweisen konnte [15].…”

A Real Nail Biter: A Cross-Sectional Study of 75 Nail Trauma Scenes in International Films and Television Series

“…Preprocedural anxiety is common in patients undergoing nail procedures. In a survey-based study of 162 general surgery patients, 1 average preprocedural fear levels were greater for those watching >20 vs. <20 hours/week of medical television ( P = .039). Since patients may associate nail procedures with onscreen “nail torture” scenes, we aimed to characterize representation of nail trauma in film and television.…”