Impact of organisational practices on the relationships between young people with disabilities and paid social support workers

Abstract

Summary This article uses Ikäheimo’s concept of institutionally mediated recognition to explore how organisational norms and rules facilitate and constrain interpersonal recognition between a young person with disabilities and their paid support worker. The experience of recognition is important because it reflects the quality of this relationship and shapes the identity of both people in the paid support relationship. To understand the relationships between the pairs, Honneth’s interpersonal modes of recognition were applied as the theoretical lens. The data were generated from photovoice, social mapping, interviews and workshops with 42 pairs of young people and their support workers in six organisations. These data were then analysed for the ways institutional practices mediated the interpersonal relationships. Findings The findings revealed four practices in which the organisational context mediated interpersonal recognition: the support sites, application of organisation policies, practices to manage staff and practices to organise young people’s support. Some organisational practices facilitated recognition within the relationships, whereas others were viewed by the pair or managers as constraints on conditions for recognition. Some young people and support workers also exercised initiative or resisted the organisational constraints in the way they conducted their relationship. Applications The findings imply that to promote quality relationships, organisations must create the practice conditions for recognition, respond to misrecognition, and encourage practices that make room for initiative and change within the paid relationship. This requires supervision and training for and by support workers and people with disability.

Day service cultures from the perspectives of autistic people with profound learning disabilities

“…At times, support workers challenge organisational practices in the interests of those they work with, to develop positive relations and improve working conditions (Fisher et al, 2021). Storytelling in The Hall helped to share practices and experiences valued by members and challenged issues faced by support staff, such as high staff turnover, though such stories were not evidenced in official service documents.…”

“…At times, support workers challenge organisational practices in the interests of those they work with, to develop positive relations and improve working conditions (Fisher et al, 2021). Storytelling in…”

Personalising Support through Communication between People with Intellectual Disabilities and their Support Workers

“…An implication is that communication can be enhanced by employment conditions that promote continuity in person-worker interactions. In addition, training and professional development can assist workers to share their knowledge about personalised communication with other workers (Dalton & Sweeney 2013;Fisher et al 2021;Iacono et al 2019;Robinson et al 2023). Sharing experiences may improve interactions through reflection.…”

Using the ‘in-between’ to build quality in support relationships with people with cognitive disability: the significance of liminal spaces and time

“…Support workers without the necessary skills (for example, in managing delicate/ difficult conversations), training and motivation, and who are poorly matched with a young person, are inevitably less likely to make the most of the opportunities presented by liminal space-times. Further, organisational training and support for workers can also be absent or inadequate in a personalised support system, with support workers often away from the organisational base, line managers and co-workers (Fisher et al, 2020).…”