Implementing integrated care pilot projects in hospital settings – an exploration of disruptive practices

Abstract

PurposeIn Canada, integrated care pilot projects are often implemented as a local reform strategy to improve the quality of patient care and system efficiencies. In the qualitative study reported here, the authors explored the experiences of healthcare professionals when first implementing integrated care pilot projects, bringing together physical and mental health services, in a community hospital setting.Design/methodology/approachEngaging a qualitative descriptive study design, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 24 healthcare professionals who discussed their experiences with implementing three integrated care pilot projects one year following project launch. The thematic analysis captured early implementation issues and was informed by an institutional logics framework.FindingsThree themes highlight disruptions to established logics reported by healthcare professionals during the early implementation phase: (1) integrated care practices increased workload and impacted clinical workflows; (2) integrating mental and physical health services altered patient and healthcare provider relationships; and (3) the introduction of integrated care practices disrupted healthcare team relations.Originality/valueStudy findings highlight the importance of considering existing logics in healthcare settings when planning integrated care initiatives. While integrated care pilot projects can contribute to organizational, team and individual practice changes, the priorities of healthcare stakeholders, relational work required and limited project resources can create significant implementation barriers.

Provider and Manager Perspectives on the Use of an Integrated Clinical Pathway for Community-Dwelling Older Adults: A Qualitative Case Study

“…Given that increased provider workload is associated with reduced quality of care in the primary care setting [ 40 ], it is important to find a balance when adopting ICPs. Evidence from another setting [ 41 ] suggests that stakeholders should pay attention to the real possibility of increased workloads when designing and implementing integrated care initiatives.…”

Implementation stages in practice: A review of behavioral health innovation within hospitals

“…Hospitals are complex and dynamic environments where collaboration is critical. 10,11 Such settings provide an exemplary proving ground for questioning whether process models are effective in complex organizations. Knowing the relative impact of implementation stages has implications for whether it is fruitful to continue research in this area, whether the frameworks are applied in real world settings, and whether their use impacts outcomes.…”

“…10 Despite its downstream benefits, integrating behavioral health into physical health services is disruptive to workflows and patient care in hospitals. 11 Many frameworks and models have been proposed to aid implementation. 12 One approach to implementation is the application of process models.…”

“…16 In addition, factors affecting implementation success vary across levels of intervention (e.g., community, organization, teams, individuals) 15,16 which is not explicitly addressed in all process models, but is particularly relevant for hospital settings. 10,11 Process models’ perceived simplicity may be appealing to implementation teams and management, yet it is unclear whether these models are effective for implementation in complex hospital settings. This review seeks to answer whether using process models aids achieving implementation outcomes.…”

Linking Ethical Standards for Healthcare Professionals with Indian Cultural Values

“…"Healthcare professional" refers to the worker who works for healthcare services, including health professional (e.g., nurse and physician), allied health professional (e.g., social worker), and healthcare manager. [32] "Ethics" is defined as the principles and moral judgments of what is right and wrong. [33] "Ethical standard" is defined as a set of acceptable actions derived from moral philosophies.…”