Implicit Gender Bias and the Use of Cardiovascular Tests Among Cardiologists

Abstract

BackgroundPhysicians' gender bias may contribute to gender disparities in cardiovascular testing. We used the Implicit Association Test to examine the association of implicit gender biases with decisions to use cardiovascular tests.Methods and ResultsIn 2014, cardiologists completed Implicit Association Tests and a clinical vignette with patient gender randomly assigned. The Implicit Association Tests measured implicit gender bias for the characteristics of strength and risk taking. The vignette represented an intermediate likelihood of coronary artery disease regardless of patient gender: chest pain (part 1) followed by an abnormal exercise treadmill test (part 2). Cardiologists rated the likelihood of coronary artery disease and the usefulness of stress testing and angiography for the assigned patient. Of the 503 respondents (9.3% of eligible; 87% male, median age of 45 years, 58% in private practice), the majority associated strength or risk taking implicitly with male more than female patients. The estimated likelihood of coronary artery disease for both parts of the vignette was similar by patient gender. The utility of secondary stress testing after an abnormal exercise treadmill test was rated as “high” more often for female than male patients (32.8% versus 24.3%, P=0.04); this difference did not vary with implicit bias. Angiography was more consistently rated as having “high” utility for male versus female patients (part 1: 19.7% versus 9.8%; part 2: 73.7% versus 64.3%; P<0.05 for both); this difference was larger for cardiologists with higher implicit gender bias on risk taking (P=0.01).ConclusionsCardiologists have varying degrees of implicit gender bias. This bias explained some, but not all, of the gender variability in simulated clinical decision‐making for suspected coronary artery disease.

The influence of patient race on the use of diagnostic imaging in United States emergency departments: data from the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care survey

“…This includes critical differences in chest pain management in ambulatory care in men vs. women, with men being 2.5 times more likely to be referred to a cardiologist than women [47]. Gender bias in health care has been well documented, [48][49][50], but further investigation of gender differences in the use of diagnostic imaging is warranted with more specifically defined clinical scenarios before firm conclusions can be drawn. The differences in imaging rates between designated urban and non-urban hospitals and between different regions of the country are also important but less easily interpreted as there is no defined "ideal" imaging rate and this may represent either under or over utilization of imaging resources.…”

Sex and gender differences and biases in artificial intelligence for biomedicine and healthcare

“…For instance, a study found that only 17% of cardiologists correctly identified women as having greater risk for heart disease than men 114 . Indeed, physicians are typically trained to recognise patterns of angina and myocardial infarction that occur more frequently in men, resulting in women being typically under-diagnosed for coronary artery disease 115 . Consequently, training an algorithm on available data on diagnosed cases could be influenced by an implicit sex and gender bias.…”

Cardiovascular Disease and the Female Disadvantage

“…A survey of American cardiologists, using simulated patients, found that they were less likely to rate the usefulness of angiography as “high” for women than for men. This implicit bias was related to their perception that women were less risk-tolerant than men [10].…”